Baseball Toaster Bronx Banter
Card Corner--Mr. Mustache
2007-12-21 05:45
by Bruce Markusen
Note: The Bronx Banter blog has moved to

There’s a myth about Reggie Jackson that most of the controversy and conflict in his career took place during his five seasons with the Yankees. That’s really not the case. While his battles of ego with Billy Martin and George Steinbrenner garnered the most media attention of his career, Jackson was just as controversial during his days in Oakland. He butted heads with manager Dick Williams and most of his coaching staff. He once fought Billy North, a onetime friend who had become a mortal enemy by 1974. Jackson frequently sparred with A’s owner/general manager Charlie Finley, who could make Boss Steinbrenner look like Charles Ingalls by comparison. One of Jackson’s controversial episodes bordered on silliness, but it was just the kind of occurrence that made life with Finley’s A’s so entertaining.

In 1972, Jackson, reported to Oakland’s spring training camp in Arizona replete with a fully-grown mustache (as seen in his 1972 Topps card, No. 435), the origins of which had begun to sprout during the 1971 American League Championship Series. To the surprise of his teammates, Jackson had used part of his off-season to allow the mustache to reach a fuller bloom. In addition, Jackson bragged to teammates that he would not only wear the mustache, but possibly a beard, come Opening Day.

Such pronouncements would have hardly created a ripple in today’s game. Players freely make bold fashion statements with mustaches and goatees, and routinely wear previously disdained accessories like earrings. It’s really no big deal in 2007. But this was 1972, still a conservative time within the sport, in stark contrast to the rebellious attitudes of younger generations throughout the country. Given that no major league player had been documented wearing a mustache in the regular season since Wally Schang of the Philadelphia A’s in 1914, Jackson’s pronouncements made major news in 1972.

In the post-Schang era, several players had donned mustaches during spring training, including Stanley "Frenchy" Bordagaray of the Brooklyn Dodgers in the mid-1930s and, more recently, Richie Allen of the St. Louis Cardinals and Clete Boyer of the Atlanta Braves in the first two years of the seventies. (Allen’s 1971 Topps card shows the mustache in clear view, but it’s believed that the Dodger Stadium photograph was taken just before the start of the season.) Yet, in each case, the player had shaved off the mustache by Opening Day, either by his own volition or because of a mandate from the team. After all, there existed an unwritten rule within the conservative sport, one that strongly frowned upon facial hair. In addition, several individual teams had more recently instituted their own formal policies (most notably the Cincinnati Reds in the 1960s), policies that forbade their players from sporting facial hair.

Baseball’s conservative grooming standards, which had been in place for over 50 years, were now being threatened by one of the game’s most visible players. Not surprisingly, Jackson’s mustachioed look quickly cornered the attention of Charlie Finley and Dick Williams. "The story as I remember it," says former A’s first baseman Mike Hegan, "was that Reggie came into spring training… with a mustache, and Charlie didn’t like it. So he told Dick to tell Reggie to shave it off. And Dick told Reggie to shave it off, and Reggie told Dick what to do. This got to be a real sticking point, and so I guess Charlie and Dick had a meeting, and they said well, ‘Reggie’s an individual so maybe we can try some reverse psychology here.’ Charlie told a couple of other guys, I don’t know whether it was [Dave] Duncan, or Sal [Bando], or a few other guys to start growing a mustache. Then, [Finley figured that if] a couple of other guys did it, Reggie would shave his off, and you know, everything would be OK."

According to A’s captain Sal Bando, Finley wanted to avoid having a direct confrontation with Jackson over the mustache. For one of the few times in his tenure as A’s owner, Finley showed a preference for a subtle, more indirect approach. "Finley, to my knowledge," says Bando, "did not want to go tell Reggie to shave it. So he thought it would be better to have all of us grow mustaches. That way, Reggie wouldn’t be an ‘individual’ [anymore]." Rollie Fingers, Catfish Hunter, Darold Knowles, and Bob Locker followed Reggie’s lead, each sprouting his own mustache. Instead of making Jackson feel less individualistic, thus prompting him to adopt his previously clean-shaven look, the strategy had a reverse and unexpected effect on Finley.

"Well, as it turned out, guys started growing ‘em, and Charlie began to like it," says Hegan in recalling the origins of baseball’s "Mustache Gang." Finley offered a cash incentive to any player who had successfully grown a mustache by Father’s Day. "So then we all had to grow mustaches," says Hegan, "and that’s how all that started. By the time we got to the [regular] season, almost everybody had mustaches." Even Dick Williams, known for his military brush-cut and clean-shaven look during his managerial tenure in Boston, would join the facial brigade by growing a patchy, scraggly mustache of his own. Baseball’s longstanding hairless trend had officially come to an end.

And as always, Finley had found a way to profit from it.

Merry Christmas, everybody!

Bruce Markusen, who writes Cooperstown Confidential for, is the author of the upcoming book, Out of Left Field: Unusual Characters in Baseball History.

2007-12-21 06:29:06
1.   RIYank
Excellent, Bruce.
But how did Finley profit from the facial hair?
2007-12-21 06:42:07
2.   Bruce Markusen
I should have made it more clear. Finley held a special "Mustache Day" at the Oakland Coliseum that season, so he got a nice little promotion out of the deal. I'll have to check the attendance for that game, but I imagine it was significantly higher than what the A's normally drew (which wasn't usually very good). Finley liked his promotions.
2007-12-21 07:29:22
3.   RIYank
So, raise your hand if you believe that Jonathan Papelbon's dog ate his WS baseball.
2007-12-21 08:00:39
4.   SF Yanks
I think Cabbage Patch ate it himself.
2007-12-21 08:03:06
5.   Raf
3 Stranger things have happened.
2007-12-21 08:12:15
6.   Yankee Fan In Boston
3 mientkiewicz was threatened with a lawsuit when he didn't surrender the ball from '04. papelbon wanted to keep the ball.

the dog story strikes me as pure ridiculousness, and the only explanation i can think of for the coverage it is receiving is that writers are sick of writing about steroids and santana and grabbed at the first fluff piece that came their way.

2007-12-21 09:18:49
7.   standuptriple
I do believe Papebag is careless enough to do that.
2 I would participate in a Mustache Day. I know there are orgs that have people grow them and get sponsors to not shave. It's a pretty creative way of generating $ for charity and getting some laughs with people who don't take themselves too seriously. I tried to get all the guys attending a bachelor party to get on board with that but the lawyers objected (shocking).
2007-12-21 09:23:22
8.   Bronxer
1 Nice article.
6 I agree that the writers picked up the world series ball story because they are sick writing about all else - Santana, Sox trade package vs. Yankee trade package ("my prospects are better than your prospects, so there"), steroids, Clemens, etc. I'm just tired of all this crap.

Merry Christmas!

2007-12-21 09:34:37
9.   SF Yanks
"With back to back games, Hughes and Chamberlain have not given up a run going a combined 14 innings and striking out 22. A new era has started."

I really can't wait to hear something like that. I hope I'm not setting myself up for disappointment. Or even better:

"For five straight games, the entire Yankee starting rotation has given up only one earned run with each starter getting the win..."

Are we there yet? Are we there yet? Are we there yet?

2007-12-21 10:26:00
10.   The Mick 536
[1,2] Just another spin on the genius of Charlie O. Rereading Juicing the Ball by Howie Bryant. I recommend it highly. He points out that baseball, while it honors individual achievement, is frowns on individualism. Perhaps, that is why A-Rod is having the problems that he has been having? By getting other players to wear facial hair (how about that stash, Rollie/Cat?), Reggie brought the whole team together.

Sal Bando's comment on Reggie is still one of my favs: "not enough mustard in the stadium for that hot dog." Or something like that.

Felt a little bad for Reggie when the Mitchell Report aired. His productivity was dissed by the Grady Anderson's of the game. Reggie never hit 50. He may not have been as great or as smart as he thought he was, but he made you stop what you were doing to watch.

2007-12-21 12:58:46
11.   glennrwordman
10 I believe that quote was from (amply mustachioed) reliever Darold Knowles...
2007-12-21 12:59:29
12.   alsep73
Wait, so Rollie Fingers may never have grown one of the great mustaches of all time if it hadn't been for Reggie? Why was that never mentioned during the run-up to his Hall of Fame induction? I'd put that only slightly behind the Mr. October game (and just ahead of the home run off the light tower) among his greatest accomplishments.

Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.