Baseball Toaster was unplugged on February 4, 2009.
You can see why people are so high on Phil Hughes. He has a nice fastball--imagine that, a Yankee starter with the ability to throw a fastball past a hitter?!--a good curve and is unafraid to throw a change-up too (at one point early in the game he threw three straight change-ups). He fell behind too many hitters, and Alex Rios and Vernon Wells hit the ball hard off him in the first inning (Frank Thomas also connected for an RBI single; Hughes made a good pitch against him, fastball on the outside corner, but The Big Hurt showed why he's a Hall of Fame hitter by slapping it into right). Hughes was just adequate last night, giving up four runs in less than five innings, but he's certainly more promising than the likes of Kei Igawa, the Bombers' new mop-up man in the bullpen.
"I certainly wasn't disappointed," Torre said. "I didn't think he was out of his league, by any stretch of the imagination."..."The big thing I saw was even when he was down, he kept coming," catcher Jorge Posada said. "That's the sign of a good pitcher. I was really happy."
(Tyler Kepner, N.Y. Times)
Unfortunately for the Yanks, Toronto's answer to Nuke Laloosh, A.J. Burnett, was in fine form, pitching seven shut-out innings. The Bombers managed only four hits all night and lost their sixth straight game. Final score: Jays 6, Yanks 0.
How could Yankee fans be anything but glum watching the game last night? Oy and veh. The most exciting moment offensively came when Alex Rodriguez hit a ball to the warning track in dead center. It sounded great but came up just short. I did notice late in the game, both Johnny Damon and Alex Rodriguez smiling, so it doesn't appear as if the players are too tight yet. After the game, however, Damon told reporters:
"There's going to be panic soon, if the winning doesn't start," Johnny Damon said, although he quickly backtracked after realizing how that honesty came across. "We're not panicking, but we need to get on track soon. It doesn't matter who we get back on track with, we just need to start winning games sometime."
(Peter Botte, N.Y. Daily News)
I think the Yanks will turn it around shortly. Surely, it can't get much worse, can it? I'm more frustrated than panicked. It is dark and rainy in New York this morning with thundershowers in the forecast for much of the day. It is also supposed to rain tomorrow. I wonder how many games the Yanks and Sox will get in?
Did you see the game last night~!?
That Hughes kid! 5 K's in 4.1 IP!
Minky had one walk! A solid BB! Meanwhile, that defense!
And Matsui - he had three walks!
Even Cairo...uh....
Always look on the bright side of life...do do..do do do do...
To co-opt an important piece of American writing for a comparatively trivial matter:
"THESE are the times that try men's souls. The summer soldier and the sunshine patriot will, in this crisis, shrink from the service of their country; but he that stands by it now, deserves the love and thanks of man and woman. . ."
http://www.ushistory.org/paine/crisis/c-01.htm
I am puzzled by Henn's line last night:
1 IP, 0 H, 2 BB 2 K 2 ER. What happened there?
Bad Hughes Bears.
The delayed steal and error said it all. The Giambi attempt to stretch a double said it all.
Pancakes in pinstripes.
My longtime buddy Jeff the Mets fan hit me with an e-mail from L.A. overnight:
>Subject: spring ball
>
>Too soon to talk about the Mets v. Yankees? I know better than to gloat--
>I'm sure the Yanks will rip off 15 of 17 games in the near future, but man
>is their rotation a MESS. I also don't know how long the Mets can win with
>four guys who graduated the same year we did in their lineup, but they're
>pretty fun to watch right now. anyway, hope all's well with you and the
>family.
>Later,
>J
my reply:
Mess? What mess? The only mess I see around here is the confetti from last night's official "Mission Accomplished" pep rally at Yankee Stadium. Sure, it
was a little premature, but we all had a good time.
Peace
If Mussina comes back healthy and they have a front three of Wang, Pettitte, Mussina pitching deep into games, they'll be OK with 5 inning starts out of the 4th and 5th spots in the rotation.
Clearly, one of those slots should belong to Phil Hughes. I actually think he looked pretty good last night. I'll discount the 1st inning to jitters and even mollify the 5th based on McDonald should have never reached base (blame Cairo or the ump, but either way he should have been out). The curve ball is what has me most excited. If he could have commanded it a little better, he would have been unhittable. The hitters were so fooled by it, they kept taking it unfortunately, it was just missing. Even if Hughes is the real deal, however, that doesn't guarantee early success. I know I'd gladly sign up for Hughes' career to mimic John Smoltz (who debuted at only a few months older than Hughes), but that first season ERA+ of 67 would be a killer this season.
Even if Hughes can be effective, that still leaves another slot. C---P----- is now dead to me. I will no longer even say his name. Unfortunately, he would have been a much better option than Karstens or Rasner. Igawa also doesn't seem to factor in because it looks as if they have already abandoned ship on him.
Any way you look at it, this rotation is a very high risk proposition. With the way the AL is stacked with good lineups and mediocre pitching, the Yankees relative strengths don't seem to match up. I am not giving up by any stretch, but I think a realistic Yankee fan now needs to look at the Red Sox as the favorite in the race while keeping an eye on the wild card.
I definitely think Phil was squeezed a few times last night, however. The strike zone was wildly inconsistent, as Frank Thomas could probably attest to when Myers came in.
So Phil can hang, that's for sure. Toronto's big bats can be brutal, and it was encouraging that the hardest hit ball last night still stayed in the yard. Although I'm not sure why Damon wasn't playing deeper...
So give the kid a few more starts until Moose comes back, then send him back to AAA to work on a third pitch. We'll see ya in August when everyone will need a little injection of youth & energy...
Should be able to park if you arrive early enough. The lots on River Avenue and 164th street seem to be the best bet. DON'T park in the lots adjacent to the Stadium.
Also Hughes did look good. First inning jitters, then he settled down. Keep him up and let him learn in the bigs. He was never challenged in AAA.
Now, if only Cashman can work some magic and get this year's version of Chacon or Small. . .
One other point about Hughes...because there isn't a better option anyway, getting a look at Hughes is also beneficial for the purposes of planning the 2008 rotation. Along those lines, if I was Cashman, I would risk the tampering charge and release an anonymous quote stating that the "Yankees intend to make Carlos Zambrano a limited partner should he opt for free agency".
Henn went walk walk to start the seventh. He was replaced by Proctor. Proctor walked the next man to load the bases. Then a wild pitch to score one of Henn's base runners, and then a sac fly to do the same.
I was a little worried for the kid in the first. Some solid contact was being made. The first inning is a tricky thing. Even vets sometimes get rocked or knocked-out early. I recognized it as an important test. Would he go the way of Daan Eveland, Edinson Volquez and Jason Hirsh of 2006 and let things spiral out of control? He didn't. He kept coming. He battled. In that alone there was something to be excited about.
From my seats in the upper deck, 1st base side, you could clearly see the bend to his hook. I don't know that it was knee buckling or that the break was sharp enough, but it wasn't the loopy, headed for the bleachers type curve either. I took note that according to the scoreboard the curve was sitting at 74, while his fastball was being clocked at 96. I wondered if that was the ideal difference in velocity.
By the 4th inning I think, I'm now on the lower deck, 3rd base side, I began to worry when I saw that his fastball was hitting 90, 91, 89. He was tiring - quickly. I figured he didn't have long, but hoped he'd get through the 5th at least. Oh, well. Better to take him out. Each pitch must have felt like 2 on the night of his debut, anyway.
I came away from the game with my original expectations intact. There's a good chance he is not a savior to the season. There's a good chance he does not go all Verlander, good-Weaver or Hamels on the AL. He may start off more like the Rocket or Kazmir. It may take a year or two or even three to get where he wants to be and where we need him to be. But, there's certainly promise there.
I agree that developing Hughes should be a priority, but as this season has shown, the Yankees will have more than a few slots to fill next season. Outside of Zambrano (or a trade for Santanna), there isn't much on the horizon.
Maybe Cliff will have a shot of her in his slide show.
Bring on the slides, Cliff!
There are reasons for concern. But, even if the back end of the rotation were to be Hughes+Karstens/Rasner/Clippard we wouldn't be the only ones with inexperienced 4/5 starters. We have a mighty offense. They have shown that in 2007, unlike the last few seasons, they can hit good pitching, not just bad mistakes by good pitchers. We will win a lot of games.
What we can't have is Minky ever batting 2nd again. I was floored when I saw Minky coming up. I kept muttering to myself about it throughout the "contest". Torre needs to wise up. He can't banish Farns if it hurts the team. Joe's got to get better. I'd hate to see his tenure end without a dignified exit. Though, I don't hate the idea enough to allow us to squander the season.
Last night we ran into: 'Good pitching beats Good hitting'. AJ had his 'A' game on. It happens.
While our SP can be pointed to (and I'm not really disagreeing) I would point out:
1) Poor defense has lost us a game or 2?
2) Blown Saves have cost us a game or 5?
3) ONE key hit in a NUMBER of chances (bases loaded and NO outs in the 8th, hit into 4 DPs in one game, etc) have cost us a few games.
So, SP has been an obvious problem, which will get much better. But we have been creative, and have thrown away Wins in quite a few ways.
Hughes is the real deal. His velocity dropped at the end, and he is not as strong or conditioned as he will be in 2008 and 2009.
I'd love to have him in 2007... but if for ANY reason he gets hurt by being UP in 2007, I will have more 'I told you so's then Jim Dean and Rob Gee at a crystal meth party.
I want to win now, but Hughes is the closest thing we've had to a golden goose in decades. I don't think we should take ANY chances with him at all. For what?? An extra run or 2 saved every 5th game?
I'm with you on the Guidry thing (I posted about that yesterday):
https://bronxbanter.baseballtoaster.com/archives/641286.html#23
Gator may not be the current problem, but unfortunately he doesn't seem to be the solution either and in the long run that could become an even bigger problem.
I think I'd rather have Kerrigan as the PC than Gator. Maybe do a flip flop with them, Gator in the Pen and and Kerrigan on the bench.
I assign most blame this season to our new conditioning coaches - everyone's getting injured (lots with the same injuries too) and everyone's tired early in the season. They supposedly changed to a new conditioning coach or conditioning regimen to improve things but it looks like things got a lot worse.
Yankees ERA+
97
137
128
101
112
Astros ERA+
145
221
197
Something's been different, cause if he was that pitcher the Yanks would have never let him leave or retire - i.e., they would have thrown too much money at him. The open question is whether he reverts back to his Yankees "form". That's good (sometimes), but not Astros good.
29 How will you connect Hughes getting hurt in 2008 or 2009 to him being up in 2007? You know cause pitchers get hurt, that's what they do. And if Hughes pitches about 180 innings, you'll have no leg to stand on, becuase that's well in line with what all the experts give as sensible for his progression. The Yanks have been, and will continue, to do it by the book. Why change course now? Because they're five games out in April? And if they fall far enough behind, there's even less reason to push Hughes. Same thing with Clemens aboard.
Re Hughes and injury:
Hughes would get injured if he wasn't held to the same restrictions as he is in AAA. 90 pitch or so limit, and MLB is more stress/IP. He could concievably pitch fewer than 180 innings and still get hurt. That aside, if he stays up he'll be no better than a super version of Jaret Wright.
I was interested in one thing Jim Kaat thought: that pitchers get stronger by throwing, not being babied. I hope that he doesn't get hurt BECAUSE he's not throwing enough. There just isn't enough health information to determine the truth behind pitch counts and the like.
Ok, just read the weather report, I think there isa very good chance of no game tonight. Which would be good. We can go with Pettitte and Wang for a two game series...
My theory on Henn is: he's pitching well out of the pen, lets not mess with a good thing. If Karstens can get that rust off and give us 5-6 innings of 4 run ball, thats all we need from him, and hes capable.
I notice Moose's rehab start got bumped due to crappy weather so he's just throwing from the pen. ANyone know when he's due to return?
How annoying was it last year after Manny stared down Proctor after hitting his home run. Why the hell didn't they whack the hell at out him next time he came to bat?
I don't think he has anything to learn in AAA, but I do want to see him keep to that 180 limit so we can have a full year of him next year.
A-Rod's fly out sounded better off the bat than Wells's double. Wind, perhaps.
BABIP vs Hughes was .500.
Lind was totally overmatched by PH heat.
A manager-type at Stan's said he wouldn't carry a #65 shirt until PH pitches well for a month. Humph, I was prepared to pay $35.
What I saw was Tavarez telling Matsuzaka to bust Rodriguez in on the hands, which is a perfectly appropriate way to pitch. Jeterleans over the plate and then lunges at the ball, so of course he gets hit when pitchers come inside.
The Yankee pitchers should do more of that, but hitting in retaliation just isn't good baseball. (Remember, every time you hit Ortiz, you've got Manny coming up next.)
Also after Jeter was hit during the Rays game, I thought that we should have tried to at least come inside a little more to Crawford in his first at bat (if he got plunked on his leg then so be it). He ended up getting a hit IIRC and did not stop there.
Again, I know it is unpopular around here, but it seems like our pitchers are afraid to pitch inside (altough it looked like Hughes did it last night) and IMO we need to protect our hitters a little more.
HBP, Yankees vs. Red Sox, 2004-2006
2004: 18 HBP by Sox, 15 by NY
2005: 10 by Sox, 6 by NY
2006: 7 by Sox, 6 by NY
That's a total difference of 8 HBP over 57 games, or 1 every 7 games.
Somehow, that just doesn't seem like an outrage to me.
But those stats do lessen the rage...a little.
Pedro was another matter.
He'd pretty much only be pitching to 1-2 batters a night so he'd never get stale, and his control is spotty anyway, which could always be used as an excuse to league officials.
Think about it - after about 10 bruised opposing batter's thighs, all it would take to protect our guys would be to have Farnswacker simply warm up in the pen. ;-)
I wonder where the Yanks stack up against the league in that stat?
Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.