Baseball Toaster Bronx Banter
So Long, Old Friend
2006-09-14 09:38
by Alex Belth
Note: The Bronx Banter blog has moved to

There is some sad news to report on this rainy afternoon in New York. Jim Kaat is retiring. Tonight and tomorrow will be his final two broadcasts for the Yankees. While I had heard that Kaat might call it quits at the end of the year, all of sudden, he's going to be gone. I don't exactly know why he's leaving before the end of the season. I can only speculate that Kaat didn't want to call attention to himself as everyone around him was gearing up for the playoffs. Regardless, Kaat deserves a long, loud ovation from Yankee fans near and far for the steady and insightful work he's provided over the years.

Man, I'm not ready to see him go and I've been feeling upset about it all morning long. I haven't always agreed with Kaat's analysis, but I have never had anything but the utmost respect for his professionalism, his eloquence and his willingness to speak his mind. He is a terrific storyteller, has an easy-going sense of humor, and has been a wonderfully measured prescence in the Yankee Universe. I remember my uncle spotting him in a bank on the Upper West Side during his stint with the Yanks at the end of his playing career, and I've always thought of him as a guy who appreciated New York City, and come to think of him as one of our (adopted) own. Richard Sandomir has a piece on Kitty today in the Times. The YES Network will have a tribute to Kaat up on their website later this afternoon, or perhaps this evening.

Kitty, you haven't even left yet and I'm missing you already. But here is wishing Kaat the best of times with his grandchildren and on the golf course down in Florida.

Comments (468)
Show/Hide Comments 1-50
2006-09-14 10:11:15
1.   Yankee Fan in Chicago
The thing I'll always remember about Kaat was his baseball card when I was a kid (born at the very end of 1969, started following basbeball in 77 or so).

Iirc his ml career started in 1959, so that by the late 70s the type on his stats on the back of the card was absolutely miniscule. I thought it was so cool, and can still remember when the 80s hit and he'd played in4 decades.

I wasn't a big card collector, so I don't recall what his card looked like in 83, his last season, but I suspect by then a magnifying glass was needed.

2006-09-14 10:30:51
2.   mehmattski
1 I couldn't find a picture of the back of a Jim Kaat card from the 70s or 80s, but here's a picture of the back of his rookie card. Sabermatricians would probably point out that his 1958 season at Chatannooga had a low 71:64 K:BB ratio, despite his apparent 19 K game that season. The bid for this card on eBay is $19.99.
(sorry, TinyURL is blocked at work)

2006-09-14 10:32:17
3.   markp
I couldn't disagree more. Kaat's incessant misinformation was infuriating to a lot of Yankee fans. Everything from shortstops and catchers not hitting before Bench and Ripkin. (The guy played in the same era as Ernie Banks, Yogi Berra, Smokey Burgess, Elston Howard, and on the same team as Zoilo Versalles and Earl Battey fer cryin out loud) to how the radar gun and pitch counts were hurting young pitchers to "you know, a team with 9 Ozzie Guillens would win a lot of baseball games" (no, they wouldn't score enough runs to break even), Kaat is the anti-Kubek.
(Tony actually tried to understand things before he gave his opinion on their usefulness.
2006-09-14 10:48:42
4.   seamus
3 do people just come to blogs to hate? I don't get it. There is noone in the world who could commentate as long as Kaat has and not infuriate someone. get over it.
2006-09-14 10:49:44
5.   Bob Timmermann
As a non-New Yorker, what was the story about Rizzuto not attending Mantle's funeral and why was it such a big deal? Or was it a big deal?
2006-09-14 10:54:22
6.   Cliff Corcoran
3 Kaat did have his weak points when it came to those sorts of statements, but I always felt that his overall skill and aplomb as an announcer far outweighed that throwback mentality. I only wish Kaat was finishing his run beside Ken Singleton, as those two--one a sabermetricly minded hitter, the other a throwback pitcher, both intelligent, charming, with deep pleasing voices, as Alex said, easy-going senses of humor, and a deep well of experience from which to draw insight and anecdotes--as a duo, without intrusion from anyone else, formed the ideal announcing team. Adding to that is that both were fiercly objective, neither having had their glory days in New York. Kaat especially should be comended for his willingness to take the team and even the owner to task when he saw fit.

We'll miss ya, Kitty. Enjoy.

2006-09-14 10:55:04
7.   Alex Belth
If I recall correctly, Scooter wasn't allowed to take the day off from the broadcast to attend the funeral. Now, Scooter has always seemed like a meek personality, and I wouldn't be surprised if some suit told him he had to work, he didn't want to riff about it and just did what he was told. But if Scooter really wanted to go to Mantle's funeral, then I'm sure he would have, and could have. Could you imagine if he had taken that story to the press? He would have been completely supported.

That's my take, but I don't recall the particulars all that well. 'Lil help...

2006-09-14 11:11:48
8.   markp
I'm not allowed to have an opinion? I know of quite a few other Yankee fans that can't stand Kay, Sterling, Waldman, and Kaat. Some of them refer to Kaat as "Uncle Stupid" because of the ridiculous reamrks he makes. His obvious dislike for some Yankees and hero worship for others is unprofessional (not having to hear how "Jeter's compact swing generates more power than Arod's, which is too long." any more is just fine with me.)

I grew up listening to Mel Allen and Red Barber. Then Scooter, Frank Messer, Bill White, Tony Kubek, etc. Guys who didn't try to psychoanalyze players, but reported on the events in the game (or in Scooter's case, were entertaining enough to not do so.)
Singleton is most like them,though he gets dragged into the psychobabble from time to time.
In any case, I think I'll reserve the right to criticize who I please. And I'm the guy that defends players far more often than criticizes them.

2006-09-14 11:18:26
9.   KJC
1 "Iirc his ml career started in 1959, so that by the late 70s the type on his stats on the back of the card was absolutely miniscule"

Yes! in my card-collecting days of the late 70's, I always loved seeing the amount of stats the "old-timers" had on the back of their cards, and Kaat's was always some of the smallest type I'd ever seen.

2006-09-14 11:21:01
10.   JL25and3
I'm not that big a Kaat fan, either. He's OK, but in recent years he's grated on me more and more. A lot of it is the throwback thing - back when pitchers were real men and threw 300+ innings a year and you finished what you started.

I also find him too McCarverish - his observations sometimes come out as pronouncements, calling attention to himself as much as to the observation.

Singleton is my current favorite. The game he did solo was an understated tour de force - I didn't realize for several innings that he was alone.

2006-09-14 11:25:51
11.   JL25and3
8 You predate me by a few years - I don't remember Allen. The first team I remember was Rizzuto, Coleman and Barber, joined later by Joe Garagiola. By that time, I think Barber was losing interest in the whole thing; or maybe I was just too young to appreciate his understated style.
2006-09-14 11:26:43
12.   rsmith51
8 I am OK with it.

It reminds me having lunch with coworkers and one of the guys said he just saw Forrest Gump and thought it was the dumbest movie he ever saw. Another guy pipes in and says maybe he didn't understand the movie cause he happened to like it.

I think maybe he just didn't like the movie.

I know I didn't like the movie Chicago, though others clearly did.

Sometimes it is OK to agree to disagree.

2006-09-14 11:27:01
13.   Travis
7 I don't know what the parameters on posting 10-year old articles here are, but here's the most comprehensive Rizzuto story I could find from August 19, 1995:

"Phil Rizzuto, a Yankees broadcaster for 39 years, a member of the Hall of Fame and perhaps the most popular announcer in New York, said Friday he has quit his job.
Rizzuto, 76, decided to resign after he missed the funeral of Mickey Mantle in Texas on Tuesday. At the behest of station executives at WPIX-TV, Rizzuto stayed in Boston and broadcast the Yankees-Red Sox game.
He left the booth after five innings, too distraught to continue, and left the stadium.
"After I saw the funeral on television, I said, `This is terrible.' I'll never be able to make up for that. If I had a little more get-up-and-go, I would have just gone on down to the funeral and let the chips fall where they may.
"I think I've definitely made up my mind, even though everybody keeps telling me I can't do this," Rizzuto said.
WPIX executives asked Rizzuto to reconsider his decision, "and he said he would," station vice president Michael Eigner said.
The next WPIX broadcast is Sunday from Anaheim. The station broadcasts 41 Yankees games a year; the rest are on cable. Rizzuto said he has an open-ended ticket to California in case he changes his mind.
"I've been there for 39 years and I'm not tired or anything, but I had relegated my family to the background, and when I saw what Mickey said about that, I thought it was about time," Rizzuto said.
Eigner said WPIX did not forbid Rizzuto from going to the funeral but wanted him to broadcast the game Tuesday because Yankees fans would want to hear Rizzuto's voice on a tribute the station had prepared.
Also, fellow announcer Bobby Murcer was a pallbearer at the funeral, and the absence of Murcer and Rizzuto would have left only one announcer in the booth.

2006-09-14 11:42:15
14.   wsporter
13 Thanks Travis, I had remembered it as the WPIX people had refused to give Phil permission to go. I guess this makes more sense. I suppose he would have quit outright and gone anyway had they simply told him he "couldn't" go. Either way it started the ball rolling toward the Scooter ultimately leaving the following year. Boy do I miss the sound of his voice.

I never really warmed up to Kaat in the way I did to the Scooter. I guess it's the difference in growing up with one and listening to the other as an adult. I didn't always agree with Kaat's opinions or follow the logic of his arguments but I did always respect him and feel that he did the games as honestly as he possibly could.

I hope Kitty has a great time seeing the country in that RV of his. Take it easy big guy, we'll leave a light on and a bowl of milk on the porch for you.

2006-09-14 11:44:49
15.   pistolpete
13 That's ridiculous - you mean to tell me that something couldn't be worked out on PIX should there have only been one announcer?

They could have simulcasted the radio broadcast or something, no?

2006-09-14 11:55:07
16.   seamus
8 i overstated my frustration with your post at 3. Sorry about that. But I never stated you couldn't have an opinion. Your original post, however, was full of embellishments. I also think that a lot of folks who criticize announcers have NO idea how hard it is to maintain conversation for the length and shifts in a ballgame and keep it interesting. The fact that announcers sometimes say things that are ridiculous or that differ from what you think should always be very high.
2006-09-14 11:56:31
17.   Shaun P
13 That sounds right. It was a sad thing all around. Thanks for digging that article up, Travis.

FWIW, I would pay a lot of money to hear Scooter and White call a current Yankees game. Doesn't matter who the 3rd guy is, Seaver, Murcer, Messer, or even if there is one. Wait, I take that back. I don't think I could bear to listen to Kubek or McCarver or Joe Morgan ruin it for me.

I too won't miss Kitty's crazy talk about pitch counts etc - but because he's generally pretty even-minded about everything else, I can ignore his tragic flaw. Unlike, say, "All the radar guns are wrong! I know a 102 mph pitch and that wasn't it" Joe Morgan, who's tragic flaw, his broadcasting career, is sadly impossible to ignore if one likes watching baseball with the volume on as I do.

For those who might still have a tiny bit of worry deep in their souls:

BP Postseason Odds
AL East - 99.99630
Wild Card - .00010
Overall - 99.99640

Red Sox:
AL East - .00330
Wild Card - .04928
Overall - .05258

2006-09-14 12:06:55
18.   JL25and3
17 Or, to put it another way: with 18 games left - 17 for the Sox - the magic number is 7. If the Sox were 14-3 down the stretch, the Yankees would only have to go 4-14 to clinch the division. Stranger things have happened, I suppose, but not much stranger.


2006-09-14 12:08:56
19.   rbj
14 I concur. Growing up with Scooter in the booth was just wonderful. Kitty couldn't replace that, but I don't think there is anyone who could. Most announcers have flaws, but after listening to so many others, I've come to appreciate Jim Kaat & John Sterling.

One guy I never could care for is Vin Scully. For some reason his voice and the way he announces (his stories, et al.,) just rub me the wrong way. The fact that it is Dodgers' games he's announcing doesn't help, either.

2006-09-14 12:09:26
20.   Travis
17 Better still, those are the Postseason Odds before yesterday's games. I would imagine the Yankees' current odds are much closer to 100%.
2006-09-14 12:10:49
21.   JL25and3
I just ran across a gem from Morgan that I scribbled down during the last Yanks-Sox series: "One thing about Red Sox fans, they know when it's a big moment. And they give their support at the right time."
2006-09-14 12:15:26
22.   markp
Embellishments? What's wrong with embellishments?

I don't care how hard announcing is. It's apparently not too hard for some people and much too hard for others.
I agree that Morgan and McCarver are worse, but the constant "this whole thing where a catcher has to hit, that started with Johnny Bench. I don't care if a guy hits 100 if he can do a good job behind the plate." He says that pretty much every game (along with several other absurdities) and it's idiotic. For one thing, there have been excellent offensive catchers since the dead ball era, including Steve O'Niell, Mickey Cochrane, Wally Shang, Hank Severeid, Johnny Bassler, Bubbles Hargrave, Frank Snyder, Gabby Hartnett, Mickey Cochrane, and Bill Dickey (all who played in the 1920s) right through to the present. Saying it all started with Bench one time is excusable. Saying it every other broadcast is nails on a blackboard to anyone that's even midly interested in baseball history. And I can't imagine many pitchers really not wanting a guy that drives in 90 runs as opposed to a guy hitting 100 in the line-up no matter where they play.
Ditto Power hitting shortstops, another silliness he often injects into his broadcasts.
Along with pitch counts, radar guns, throwing breaking balls,and over-analyzing a players psyche (another field he knows zero about but talks about at great length.)
If you're going to be making pronouncements game after game, at least try to learn if there's a lick of accuracy in them.

2006-09-14 12:20:11
23.   bp1
Too many games on TV now. Too many opportunities to hear the same comments, the same war stories, the same jokes. I don't mind, 'cause I'd much rather have the games to watch than not. There isn't a broadcaster alive or dead who wouldn't get stale doing as many games as the YES guys do. I can't think of another set of announcers I'd rather listen to six or seven times a week.
2006-09-14 12:23:08
24.   seamus
22 i'm not sure if you are responding to me, but the pressure on catchers to be hitters in order to start on all teams is a fairly new trend. Kaat isn't saying that catchers never hit, but that it is much more of a prerequisite to being a mlb starter anymore. Same thing goes for infielders with power.

What is wrong with embellishments? When they are used to ignore the merit in what someone is saying or the value of their contributions they serve only one purpose - to make yourself feel better about yourself.

2006-09-14 13:15:51
25.   Alvaro Espinoza
8 If Kaat is "Uncle Stupid", I'm dying to hear the nicknames for Sterling, Waldman and Kay...
2006-09-14 13:16:52
26.   Sliced Bread
I very much enjoyed listening to Kaat over the years, and missed him a lot when I was living in L.A. in the late 90's/early 00's, as I had to catch the radio broadcasts on the computer.

You're never going to agree with an announcer 100% of the time.

For me, the best ones are not intrusive, but are easy on the ear, and offer relevant observations. Kitty was all that, and then some, providing fun and insightful baseball stories which were almost always relevant to the game situation.

At least that's how I heard him.

Great work, Jim Kaat. I'm gonna miss you.

Thankfully, we still have Singleton.

2006-09-14 13:32:16
27.   JL25and3
Sterling's nickname could be "Baseball is the most unpredictable sport." Or maybe just Harold Moskowitz.
2006-09-14 13:35:18
28.   Ron Burgundy
Jim Kaat, we will miss you. I'll always remember your pure humbleness and great stories of the game. And I'll always remember your terrific pitching insight.
2006-09-14 13:35:50
29.   pistolpete
22 Umm, no Joe - if anything, catchers hitting more than their weight started with one Lawrence Peter Berra. ;-)
2006-09-14 13:41:00
30.   Bama Yankee
I've had the Extra Innings package for the last three years and MLB.TV for the last two. One thing I have discovered during that time is that the Yankee announcers are head and shoulders above what most teams try to pass off as "announcers". Not to mention the ESPN and FOX crews that are forced upon us due to blackout restrictions.

Of course if you want you can always find something about any announcer that you don't like (someone earlier even said that they didn't like Vin Scully). With three hours of time to fill in a sometimes slow game, it has got to be difficult to be fresh and creative every night.

Overall, I think Kaat does a great job and I will surely miss him. Those who don't like him should try listening to Hawk Harrelson, Joe Morgan, Tim McCarver or Tom Paciorek on a regular basis.

2006-09-14 13:46:53
31.   Bama Yankee
29 and third basemen hitting less than their weight started with one Dale Anthony Berra. ;-)
2006-09-14 13:56:56
32.   vockins
30 Ron Santo makes Jim Kaat sound like a hybrid of Winston Churchill and Casey Stengel.

We've got it way, way better than most Yankee fans realize, not that there's no room for improvement.

2006-09-14 14:03:07
33.   Travis
30 32 I agree with you about the Yankee TV announcers being generally much better than those for most of the league, but I firmly believe that Sterling and Waldman are among the worst radio duos in the history of baseball. Announcers from the 1930's who recreated road games were probably more descriptive.
2006-09-14 14:08:10
34.   Travis
As per Torre on WFAN, Wang was bumped to tomorrow because of the weather, and Karstens will start tonight.
2006-09-14 14:08:36
35.   standuptriple
33 Please don't start a Sterling/Waldman bash-session. I don't think the server can take it.
2006-09-14 14:13:25
36.   Sliced Bread
34 I was hoping they'd bump him to the Sox series regardless of the weather. Not that the Sox series is any more meanigful, but they're a better team/challenge for Wang to face as he begins to tune up for the playoffs.

Are we going to get this game in? Weather Channel says 70% chance of rain all night. It'll be sloppy but I figure they'll try to squeeze it in.

2006-09-14 14:13:59
37.   randym77
30 100% agreed. Heck, I'd take the YES guys over most of the national announcers. Kay is the one that I find annoying, but he's much better than the idiots we usually get on ESPN or Fox.

I always liked Kitty. They've been talking about his retirement for weeks now, but I still find it hard to believe he's really going. I guess I can't blame him for wanting to retire, though. I know I would if I could!

2006-09-14 14:15:55
38.   Sliced Bread
Any chance Karstens could take Lidle's postseason spot? Most certainly not, but unfortunately, it seems to be a fair question at this point.
2006-09-14 14:16:28
39.   Javi Javi
30 I could not agree more with 'Bama. These days, if the EI game is not the YES telecast, I will mute the game and put Sterling and Waldman on the internet. It requires having Tivo and pausing the TV so that the internet audio can catch up. I would rather go through all that trouble, and listen to Sterling and Waldman (whom I don't really like) than have to deal with Hawk "he gone" Harrelsen and his ilk.

All of you locals to the NY area have no idea how good you have it, regarding announcers. I will miss Kitty, I think he is the best of the TV pack, and wish it was Kay who was the one who is leaving.

2006-09-14 14:18:09
40.   Paul in Boston
I like Kaat (and will miss him), Singleton (a lot), and sort of Murcer.

Kaye is lousy.

I've always had a soft spot for Sterling -- his enthusiasm for baseball just makes me smile, no matter how inane or repetitive. I wish he'd drop his stupid home run calls ("robbie cano, don't you know ..." etc). Waldman is ok.

Up here in Boston, Orsillo and Remy on TV are both excellent. But Castiglione and Trupiano on the radio are like nails on a blackboard ...

2006-09-14 14:26:47
41.   wsporter
29 I don't think either Bill Dickey or Mickey Cochrane weighed 300 pounds or more. ;-)
2006-09-14 14:31:36
42.   Bama Yankee
40 Paul, I agree with you about the NESN guys. Jerry Remy and Don Orsillo are very solid announcers, not the "homers" that you find on most networks. They even criticize the Sox on occasion and are even sometimes open minded about the Yankees (not the constant complaints about payroll like you hear from most crews).
2006-09-14 14:34:19
43.   Sliced Bread
So now with Wang going tomorrow night, and Unit, Moose, and Wright already scheduled to pitch this weekend, the Yanks' most likely playoff starters will face the Red Sox.
The Ghost Sox are probably the closest thing the Yanks will see to a playoff opponent until next month, so it will be a nice tune up series for the starters.
2006-09-14 14:37:20
44.   rbj
No Wang tonight, and probably rain? Good thing I'll be at the Mudhens' game. Governer's Cup series is tied up 1-1, best of 5.

And FWIW, the Mudhens' announcers (spilt between radio and tv) are pretty good.

2006-09-14 14:37:41
45.   yankeemonkey
I don't know if they'll get the game was beginning to clear up, but got much darker again. Keeping fingers crossed.
2006-09-14 14:42:18
46.   Sliced Bread
The Rays aren't scheduled to be back in NY, and I'm sure the Yanks don't want to waste one of the last few off days making it up, so they'll probably push for it tonight.
Score early, Yanks!
2006-09-14 14:47:38
47.   wsporter
Staten Island's game tonight has been called because of rain. Uh oh. It's raining down here in the DC area and Baltimore. No movement tonight. May have to repeat the "masacre" to clinch with the Sawx in town.
2006-09-14 14:48:42
48.   Jeb
Has anyone got a lineup for tonight yet?
2006-09-14 14:50:21
49.   randym77
44 Caught some of the Mudhens radio broadcasts when they played the Clippers. I thought they were pretty good, too.

Tommy John is one of the Charlotte Knights' color guys. He annoyed me at first, because he's a real chatty Kathy. Talks constantly - to the point that the play-by-play guy can't get a word in edgewise (which means sometimes you're left wondering what the heck is going on in the game). But he kind of grew on me. He was interesting. At least he talked about baseball, if not about the game being played. Unlike the ESPN guys, who talk about things not remotely related to baseball.

2006-09-14 14:56:58
50.   jalexei
Well - I'll miss Kittie, but maybe less for some of the reasons others have stated.

While I don't have the knowledge of the game that many do here, I often suspected some/much of Kaat's analysis was BS, but I enjoyed him on an more elemental level, just the tone and cadence of his voice seemed to work well for baseball broadcasts. That voice also seemed to contrast well with both Singleton's and Murcer's. I grew up with Rizzuto and White, and I consider the current crop (minus Kaye, though I don't dislike him as strongly as some here) pretty comparable to them.

Kaat also had some of the best "ex-player" stories among broadcasters.

And one on level it pains me to say it, but as someone with the Extra Innings package who watches a LOT of baseball in addition to the Yanks, Remy and Orsillo are the best broadcasters I've listened to. Knowledge of the game, good voices for broadcasting (especially Orsillo's) and while they clearly root for the Sox, they are always quick to give credit and respect to opponents when due.

I know people love Vin Scully, but listening to his meandering stories about what the shortstop does in the off-season up in his hunting cabin in Montana drives me nuts. I suspect the Royals guys are often drunk (though watching 162 games of KC ineptitude might drive me to the bottle), and the White Sox crew I find the most openly partisan. The SF guys aren't too bad, but for some reason Giants home broadcasts really cut the crowd noise, so they sound like they're in some small room across the Bay watching it on TV.

I'm also slightly embarrassed to admit I've been enjoying the Met broadcasts with Hernandez and Darling. They're a little goofy but generally entertaining (kind of like the Mets, I guess...)

Show/Hide Comments 51-100
2006-09-14 15:03:32
51.   randym77
Oh, boy. I think the rain has dictated the lineup...


Karstens P

2006-09-14 15:07:33
52.   Schteeve
Bernie is leading off? Say what?
2006-09-14 15:08:06
53.   seamus
51 are you pulling our legs randy?
2006-09-14 15:08:37
54.   randym77
I guess I should listed the positions, given how odd this lineup is:

Bernie CF
Jeter SS
Cano 2B
A-Rod 3B
Giambi 1B
Jorgie C
Matsui DH
Guiel RF
Thompson LF

Karstens P

All the starting OFers are getting the night off.

2006-09-14 15:09:17
55.   Javi Javi
51 That's a spring training in September lineup. Bernie leading off?
2006-09-14 15:09:45
56.   randym77
53 I'm not kidding. That's the lineup, according to both YES and USA Today.
2006-09-14 15:11:38
57.   markp
jalexei-I agree about a lot of the other announcers, especially Scully and his clone Jon Miller.
My favorite is Jim Palmer-very well spoken and one of the smartest (is it odd that two of the best announcers came from Earl Weaver's O's? I don't think it is.)
I've never understodd the animosity to homers. If Hawk Harrelson wants to openly root for the Chisox, why shouldn't he? I'd rather listen to somebody root for the team they cover than pretend to be impartial.
I agree with whoever lumped Kaat with McCarver and that group. And I agree that he's light years better than Kay and Waldman (and they're both much better than the god-awful Joe Morgan.)
2006-09-14 15:11:43
58.   randym77
Wow, it's official. The Columbus Clippers will no longer be the Yankees' Triple-A team:

2006-09-14 15:16:15
59.   Jeb
I have never understood the hatred of John Sterling. He's not like that doofus in St. Louis (Mike Shannon?) who actively cheers for home runs ("Get up, Get up, GET UP!!!!") or that imbecile in Chicago ("he gone!!!").

Sterling has a great voice, calls the game well, and yeah he gets excited win the Yanks homer or win, but when the other team homers I hear excitement in his voice as I did last night when Baldelli homered.

Waldman is terrible. Maybe she is the problem -- bring back Charlie Steiner?

2006-09-14 15:16:39
60.   randym77
57 I don't mind announcers rooting for their hometown teams. What bugs me are the ones who discount what the opposing players are doing. (And it would bug me if the Yankees announcers did it, too.) If someone hits the ball well or makes a great catch, admit it. Give him his props. Don't start moaning about the "terrible luck" that took away the hometown boy's hit.
2006-09-14 15:17:53
61.   Jeb
I meant "when" the Yanks hit a homer
2006-09-14 15:18:10
62.   Sliced Bread
I'm surprised Fasano isn't going tonight. He's a mudder. Well, he always appears to be running in mud.
2006-09-14 15:19:37
63.   seamus
56 wow. is there a possibility of a rainout? I guess Wang starts tomorrow?
2006-09-14 15:21:01
64.   randym77
Yes, Wang will go tomorrow.
2006-09-14 15:21:40
65.   Javi Javi
58 Shrug. I bet Cashman is looking for a place with more convenient direct flights than Columbus.
2006-09-14 15:24:19
66.   randym77
65 Or even so close flights aren't required. Like Scranton, PA.

It is believed that Yankees general manager Brian Cashman wants his triple-A team closer to New York. Scranton, Pa., approximately 120 miles west of New York City, is available since the Philadelphia Phillies allowed their contract to lapse. The team currently known as the Scranton/Wilkes-Barre Red Barrons will play in Allentown in 2008, and Philadelphia is rumored to be planning to play its top minor-league team in Ottawa for the 2007 season.

2006-09-14 15:27:06
67.   wsporter
58 Wow, sorry about that. Scranton/Wilkes Barre is a haul from South Central Ohio and from Northern Virginia. Oh well, they'll still come through VA Beach and Richmond I hope.

Good news on the Liriano kid at Lefties who can throw like he does are a gift from god. Gotta root for him getting back on the field in one piece.

2006-09-14 15:42:00
68.   Bama Yankee
57 I guess my problem with an announcer rooting for his hometown team (especially the over the top guys like Hawk) is that is just seems unprofessional. I mean, they are being paid to tell us what is going on during the game and add analysis (usually from a former player's perspective - which makes me wonder why they chose Waldman). If they want to root for their team, they should buy a ticket and sit in the stands.

I guess I understand why the announcers on local networks are homers, since their games are usually only seen by fans of the local team. But with a national network and with the advent of EI and MLB.TV they should realize that some people might be watching the game and actually rooting for the other team.

To me it's kind of like watching a game in your living room with a fan of another team. Would you want to watch a Yankees-Red Sox game with a Boston fan openly rooting against you in your living room? If you are at the game or in a bar it's understandable, but if he does it in my living room that Boston fan would probably leave with more than a bloody sock...

2006-09-14 15:49:16
69.   randym77
YES said the original lineup had Melky resting tonight (finally!). Damon was in CF, Abreu in RF, and Bernie in LF.

Joe, worrying about the wet outfield, decided to bench all the first stringers. Which mean moving Bernie to CF, and putting Guiel and Thompson in the corners.

Arrghh. I know it doesn't matter now, but jeez...Bernie? You've got Guiel, and Thompson, and Wilson, who are all adequate corner OFers, and it's Bernie he puts in?

2006-09-14 15:51:17
70.   Travis
(small voice) I kind of like Hawk Harrelson. I don't know why.

I hate to say it, but the best local TV announcers I've watched this year are the Mets guys when Hernandez is there.

Worst, without question: the Nationals. Way too homerish, in a fake way, and without an ounce of insight.

2006-09-14 15:55:04
71.   Javi Javi
70 You have got to be kidding re: the Hawk. "the good guys"? "he gone"? the man is atrocious.
2006-09-14 15:57:23
72.   Travis
71 Hawk's an idiot, but he knows it. I'd take him over Joe Buck any day.
2006-09-14 15:59:30
73.   seamus
72 joe buck is a really good announcer. those of us who revil in being super knowledgeable may not understand it, but he is phenomenal at what he does.
2006-09-14 16:01:12
74.   wsporter
69 If Mr. Torre wants to give GOB a night in CF with an 11.5 game lead on September 14 with the D-Rays in town I won't complain.

70 Travis, boy did you nail those Nats broadcast clowns to a T. You cannot listen to the broadcast, believe me I've tried. Talk about phoney baloney passion, it's a freakin nightmare. All that sturm and drang about the NESN broadcast rights and they give us this dreck? Oye.

2006-09-14 16:03:22
75.   mikeplugh
I was still posting over at Ho Hum for some reason. ;) Wondered why I was the only one there...

Had this to say:

Bernie leading of and Matsui batting 7th means that at this point in the season Joe feels more comfortable with GOB hitting more in a game than he does Godzilla....stunning.

How about:


Doesn't that make more sense?

2006-09-14 16:03:30
76.   Travis
73 Good at selling Budweiser? Fine. Personifying the FOX brand? Yeah. Calling a baseball game in an enjoyable, informative way? Not so much.
2006-09-14 16:03:31
77.   wsporter
73 Seamus would you mind explaining exactly what it is "he does"? Thanks!
2006-09-14 16:09:43
78.   yankz
72 You do realize how little you're saying, right? I'd take nails on a chalkboard over Joe Buck.
2006-09-14 16:10:44
79.   Javi Javi
72 Frying pan or fire? tought call between those two clowns. I'm still sore over having to hear Joe Buck calling the last out of last year's world series everytime I logged into MLB.TV this season. "over the head of Jenks . . ." ugh.
2006-09-14 16:11:09
80.   pistolpete
Oh cripes - what is it with Baldelli and leading off the game?
2006-09-14 16:12:06
81.   Yankee Fan in Chicago
Bernie triple?
2006-09-14 16:12:28
82.   Sliced Bread
75 Yeah, your lineup makes more sense, but swapping Damon for Bernie requires less thought (they have the same arm), and Bernie's been asking Joe about his role going forward, so it's mostly Joe throwing him a bone. I have no problem with that
2006-09-14 16:13:43
83.   David
74 it wouldn't bother me to see Bernie start in center field tonight, if I didn't think Joe will do the same thing in the playoffs.

Melky and Godzilla are both experienced center fielders. Joe has defined Melky as purely a left fielder. He has said the Matsui will only DH. When Johnny Damon doesn't start in a post-season game, I think Bernie will start in his place.

2006-09-14 16:13:51
84.   bballman92192
i think damon has a stronger arm then bernie
2006-09-14 16:13:54
85.   Travis
79 Beats the call you had to hear when you had to log in to MLB.TV last year.
2006-09-14 16:16:23
86.   Sliced Bread
84 Not by much.
2006-09-14 16:16:41
87.   randym77
83 "it wouldn't bother me to see Bernie start in center field tonight, if I didn't think Joe will do the same thing in the playoffs."

Exactly. I also think he'd start Bernie in the corners first, if any of the starters can't play.

2006-09-14 16:18:04
88.   yankeemonkey
Ohhh yeah, that was a Bernie triple. I swear every time he's in the filed, he looks worse than the day before. Painful...

It was interesting to read his comments in the Post (?) today about his general unhappiness about playing time. I mean, wasn't his role supposed to be PH-ing, DH-ing and spelling the OFers occassionally? The only reason he got more playing time is because of all the injuries...and now he's bitching? C'mon!

Meanwhile, 23, baby!

2006-09-14 16:18:33
89.   yankz
Oh Captain, you and your streak...

Trails Mauer by 2 points.

2006-09-14 16:18:40
90.   yankeemonkey
Ohhh yeah, that was a Bernie triple. I swear every time he's in the filed, he looks worse than the day before. Painful...

It was interesting to read his comments in the Post (?) today about his general unhappiness about playing time. I mean, wasn't his role supposed to be PH-ing, DH-ing and spelling the OFers occassionally? The only reason he got more playing time is because of all the injuries...and now he's bitching? C'mon!

Meanwhile, 23, baby!

2006-09-14 16:19:40
91.   yankeemonkey
Urgh, sorry for the double post...

::shakes fist at the stupid internet connection::

2006-09-14 16:20:45
92.   wsporter
83 I see. Who is it that you see making the PS roster that should spell Damon in CF in the playoff's? With a 2 days on one day off format how many games is Damon going to sit? I really don't think we have to worry about it.
2006-09-14 16:20:54
93.   Yankee Fan in Chicago
Next time Bernie bitches about his playing time someone should tack his lefty/righty splits to his locker.

If he's still complaining, then put together a little best of dvd of his outfield play over the last 2-3 seasons.

I love you Bernie, but you're an old fart.

2006-09-14 16:21:29
94.   Simone
The captain's hitting streak goes on. I enjoyed Bob Ryan's article supporting Derek for the AL MVP. I was uncertain before, but Ryan's "winning player" looking beyond the stats argument has convinced me. MVP! MVP!
2006-09-14 16:25:47
95.   C2Coke
Papi, take another look. Cap'n is making too strong of a case.
2006-09-14 16:26:40
96.   yankeemonkey
Is the Boston game being rain-delayed?
2006-09-14 16:28:11
97.   wsporter
96 No!
2006-09-14 16:29:53
98.   randym77
88 Not only that, but Bernie can't play very often. He sucks when he does.

When Damon was having his back problems, and Bernie played CF two days in a row, he went 0 for 5 the second day. He gets visibly tired after playing CF, or even DHing two or three days in a row.

2006-09-14 16:30:38
99.   singledd
Joe will give Bernie as much of a shot at the PS as possible... so he won't let him get too rusty. Last year, when Bernie lead off, he actually did pretty well.

I grew up on The Scooter, Coleman and Joe G. They were more entertaining then most sitcoms... for a Yankee team that stunk. I was to young to know if they were 'any good', but I loved them.

But even Scooter told some stories over and over, and had his own schtick (sp?). No announcer is perfect, and they do have to fill an incredible amount of time. All in all, Kitty was one of the best, and I will certainly miss him.

Is Leiter his replacement?

2006-09-14 16:31:36
100.   Simone
Will Karstens be on the post season roster?
Show/Hide Comments 101-150
2006-09-14 16:32:20
101.   yankeemonkey
Is this Shields person another Cy URP?
2006-09-14 16:35:08
102.   Sliced Bread
Gotta say the Bernie bashing around here bums me out. You don't want to see Bernie play anymore? Do me, and Mr. Williams a favor, and don't cheer for him when he comes through for the team. Call him a ghost, laugh and lament how his game has diminished, because that's what Bernie bashing baseball geniuses do best. I'm over it.
2006-09-14 16:36:15
103.   yankeemonkey
2006-09-14 16:36:23
104.   yankz
Oh HELL yes!!!!!!!!!
2006-09-14 16:36:26
105.   Simone
Godzilla is a beast! Matsui-san rocks!
2006-09-14 16:36:49
106.   randym77
I don't mind Bernie at the plate, in the right situation. I don't want to see him in the outfield any more. As someone else said, it's just painful. I don't want to remember him that way.
2006-09-14 16:36:51
107.   rsmith51
I was just thinking that Matsui didn't look that comfortable at the plate.
2006-09-14 16:37:13
108.   C2Coke
It's like Matsui never left. I can feel all the screams from Japan. mikeplugh, back me up.
2006-09-14 16:37:48
109.   wsporter
This is just silly isn't it? ZILA!!!!!
2006-09-14 16:40:31
110.   randym77
Woot! Go-Go Godzilla!

I swear, he's even better now than he was before he broke his wrist.

2006-09-14 16:40:42
111.   C2Coke
I still can't believe he just comes back like this. To think we might have another one in a few days. Insanity. I would hate not to see Melky playing everyday (and he finally has the day off), but at this rate, Matsui will be back in front of that Japanese ad in no time.
2006-09-14 16:40:42
112.   yankeemonkey
That was an absolute moonshot...beeeautiful!

102 Like 106 says, Bernie with the bat is fine. Bernie with the glove, not so much. I love him, he's one of my favorites, but I also look at things objectively. Bernie in the field at this point is detrimental to the team. Not bashing him, just stating the obvious. If you don't agree, that's fine, but let's call a spade a spade...

2006-09-14 16:40:50
113.   3rd gen yankee fan
I have what might be a dumb question. If the Clippers are no longer going to be the Yankees AAA affiliate, what happens to the guys like Hughes & the Kevins, who we are expecting to come up to the Yanks sometime?
2006-09-14 16:41:13
114.   singledd
I also like the line-up. Smart? Not really. Fun? Yeah! Bernie leading off... Cano batting third (a look into the future?), KT in the game.

For Mr. Steady, Joe Torre, this is like 'winging it'. And we're still gonna win the game.

Lets have some fun. Maybe we will even see Donnie PH.

2006-09-14 16:42:09
115.   yankeemonkey
115 And Gator out of the bullpen late in the game? Hell yeah!
2006-09-14 16:42:25
116.   bballman92192
yah ha ha
2006-09-14 16:42:34
117.   Yankee Fan in Chicago
102 Bernie vs right-handed pitching:


I mean, c'mon dude, that Womackian territory.

We can beat up on Torre for playing Womack, but we can't when he does the same with Bernie cause he used to be a great player?

2006-09-14 16:42:46
118.   C2Coke
Apparently, many people wants that LF job. Nice catch by Thompson.
2006-09-14 16:43:01
119.   wsporter
110 Remember when he hurt his left ankle last year and it forced him to keep his weight back? I wonder if he's got the same thing going now?

Nice play KT!

2006-09-14 16:43:05
120.   yankeemonkey
WTF? Effin' Baldelli...
2006-09-14 16:43:50
121.   randym77
113 They'll go to the Yankees new Triple-A affiliate. Whatever that is. (The Scranton Red Barons?)
2006-09-14 16:44:27
122.   bballman92192
nice play jeter
2006-09-14 16:44:50
123.   Sliced Bread
I wasn't venting 102 at anyone in particular.

Just please respect Joe's relationship with Bernie, and accept that he's going to play him from time to time, especially if he knows or thinks this might be Bernie's finall weeks.

I don't think Joe will put Bernie in a situation where he will hurt the team in October. In other words, as wsporter posted above, it's very unlikely he'll be put in the field next month, unless it's in a blow out.

2006-09-14 16:45:04
124.   3rd gen yankee fan
121 Thanks. But then what happens to Columbus?
2006-09-14 16:46:22
125.   Yankee Fan in Chicago
124 There's several ml teams without a AAA team at the moment, including the O's.
2006-09-14 16:46:49
126.   bballman92192
yah nd look how they are turning out to be
2006-09-14 16:46:56
127.   randym77
119 They said something about him being forced to use his right hand/arm more, which is the arm that generates the power for a lefty batter.
2006-09-14 16:47:03
128.   yankeemonkey
124 What are you talking about? The O's ARE a AAA team...
2006-09-14 16:47:08
129.   C2Coke
117 You may be right in theory, but Bernie is no Womack, and he would never be in the minds of Yankees fans and Torre. He may be the ghost of Bernie from time to time, or the good old Bernie a few times, but he is no Womack.
2006-09-14 16:48:07
130.   bballman92192
who do you gust think will start game one in the playoffs??
2006-09-14 16:48:51
131.   randym77
124 Columbus will try to court a new Triple-A team. They're building a new stadium, so they kind of have to.
2006-09-14 16:49:19
132.   yankeemonkey
Moose or Randy, I would think. Even though Wang would probably be the better choice.
2006-09-14 16:49:29
133.   singledd
123 I brought it up last night (unsuccessfully) for discussion. Bernie says he wants to play next year. Do we sign him? Or see him in the uniform of a lowly team?
2006-09-14 16:49:54
134.   wsporter
124 The Yankees are still in privity of contract with the players in their system including those that were lodged with the Columbus Clippers.

Columbus remains a city in Ohio, beyond that who knows. ;-)

2006-09-14 16:50:08
135.   bballman92192
132 moose is going to start because of past experince in the post season in my opinin wang deserves more than both of them
2006-09-14 16:51:20
136.   bballman92192
how do you underline that number nd put it in blue?
2006-09-14 16:51:41
137.   randym77
133 I think Torre will keep him on the team as long as he wants to be there. He was talking about not only next year, but a couple of years after that.

Cashman might be more hard-headed. I'm hoping he'll convince Bernie to sign on as a coach or something instead.

2006-09-14 16:51:41
138.   yankeemonkey
133 Looks like Kevin Thompson is saying "What about me?"
2006-09-14 16:52:32
139.   yankeemonkey
136 Put the # in []
2006-09-14 16:52:33
140.   bballman92192
yo guys how do you underline the number that you are referring to nd put it in blue?
2006-09-14 16:53:00
141.   bballman92192
ahhhh thanks monkey
2006-09-14 16:53:22
142.   Sliced Bread
133 I'd rather see a kid come up and get the at-bats, but Bernie still provides enough bang for a million bucks. And he's still worth a helluva lot more than 1/200th of the Yanks payroll. That said, I hope he decides to retire, and makes the decision easier for the Yanks.
2006-09-14 16:53:37
143.   bballman92192
139 just makin sure it works
2006-09-14 16:54:55
144.   3rd gen yankee fan
131 OH. I get it. Thanks.
2006-09-14 16:55:10
145.   Sliced Bread
133 I don't see Bernie playing elsewhere.
2006-09-14 16:55:47
146.   bballman92192
144 that was kind of delayed lol
2006-09-14 16:56:19
147.   3rd gen yankee fan
134 Columbus: a pee break on the way down to Cincinnati.
2006-09-14 16:56:36
148.   Yankee Fan in Chicago
133 How about Bernie as a player coach, give him some atbats as a dh against lefties.

And promise him headliner status at a nightclub in the new Yankee Stadium from 2009.

2006-09-14 16:57:48
149.   yankeemonkey
Gaaahhh! Definitely an URP...
2006-09-14 16:58:59
150.   rsmith51
Bernie would probably retire rather than play for another team. The Yankees already have a full-time DH. I think this will be his last year as a Yankee.
Show/Hide Comments 151-200
2006-09-14 16:59:05
151.   C2Coke
133 Suddenly, we may have an over crowded off field. As much as Bernie is loved in NY, there is no place but the bench for him next year. And he can't even be the first bench guy (there are barely enough seats), we still have a guy named Cairo and perhaps Melky next year as well.
2006-09-14 16:59:57
152.   Max
95 Papi-gate should have played itself out by now, but it is really a textbook case on how NOT to handle the media in ravenous markets like Boston and New York.

I was listening to an interview with Papi this afternoon on one of the baseball shows on XM, and I didn't expect much, but he started going off on how the media was blowing up his comments out of proportion because of the coming series with the Yankees, and how unfair and "low" it was for "the media" to make it appear that he didn't respect Jeter.

In other words, it's all a media creation, and of course, Papi went on to suck up to the Cap about how great a player he is, how everyone in baseball loves to see him play, bla bla bla.

I really think Ortiz is a good guy who got caught being a little too honest in front of the mike, and he definitely said a couple of really dumb things -- anyone as media-savvy as him should never be caught saying anything like "come hit in this lineup, and see how you do". But he's between a rock and a hard place now -- he can't be too candid about how dumb his comments were, because that would imply that he did have less respect for Jeter's credentials relative to Dye or Morneau or any other big bopper, even if he's apologetic and remorseful post-brainfart.

Major media simply doesn't let stars off the hook that easy with comments like that, and you wonder what Jetes himself thinks and how much of a grudge he's going to hold.

So Ortiz is now crying about being a victim of "the media". It sounds pretty bad, though...really insincere whining, honestly, and very uncharacteristic of him. I think he's better off saying he's spoken to Jeter privately, and that he won't talk about the matter any more.

2006-09-14 17:00:36
153.   randym77
The Clippers used to be the Pittburgh Pirates' Triple-A team. So they've been through this before. Columbus keeps the "team" - but only the name, logo, uniforms, stadium, etc. The players all belong to the Yankees, and will go to Scranton or wherever the Yanks' new Triple-A team is.

Columbus will now try to get the Mets or some other team to make the Clippers their Triple-A team.

2006-09-14 17:00:47
154.   yankeemonkey
151 I thought Cairo was only signed for this year, no? And I can't see Melky going anywhere unless he gets traded.
2006-09-14 17:00:59
155.   C2Coke
151 And of coourse, I meant Out field.
2006-09-14 17:03:39
156.   C2Coke
154 I somehow think Cairo will be back. Melky is most likely getting benched next year. Hopefully, he gets some alternate days to play in order to rest all the "veteran" guys, in other words, old guys.
2006-09-14 17:03:57
157.   wsporter
147 I suggest combining that pee with a stop at the Motorcycle Hall of Fame. You can satisfy two inescapable urges with one satisfying visit.
2006-09-14 17:04:10
158.   LI yankee
Mauer grounds out, down to .347
2006-09-14 17:04:54
159.   Sliced Bread
152 The Big Pouti thing will get plenty of play over the weekend, but I suspect it will blow out to sea by the time the Sox leave town. His hissy fit was out of character, but he's charismatic enough that it will probably be forgiven soon, if not forgotten.
2006-09-14 17:06:01
160.   yankeemonkey
....Kaat just said Torre put Karstens into the lineup without finding out what his throwing schedule was. What the...?
2006-09-14 17:06:26
161.   C2Coke
I gotta say, Wang now looks like an Ace just sitting in the dugout. He no longer hides in the corners (except on his pitching days), he now enjoys his time talking and chilling out with other players.
2006-09-14 17:06:54
162.   Sliced Bread
152 The less Pouti says about it at this point, the better for everyone.
2006-09-14 17:08:49
163.   C2Coke
160 Torre obviously was more concerned about Wang's case.
2006-09-14 17:11:15
164.   yankeemonkey
3 outs on 4 pitches? ::weeps::
2006-09-14 17:11:33
165.   randym77
I don't think Wang was ever as quiet with his teammates as he was with the press. Even early this season, I'd always see him at the dugout rail, usually with other recent Columbus escapees. (Bubba, Andy, Reese, etc.) Talking, laughing, and eating sunflower seeds. :)
2006-09-14 17:12:09
166.   Max
162 Agreed. Like I said, it's over as far as I'm concerned...he's a great hitter and personality, and I don't need to see the guy taken down a few notches. I do like him, but I was struck at how...ungraceful....he sounded in making his case. He needs to lay low and let people forget his words as quickly as possible.
2006-09-14 17:13:24
167.   marc
What is this obsession with Bernie here. We had some of the same posts last year and now again this year. Someone would think he's out in the outfield with a walker and a stump for an arm. The guy's been extremely valuable this year with all the huge injuries especially in the OF. The guy can still play. Is he still great, no he's mediocre at best as a starting outfielder on the Yanks. And that's why he's not. But he's an excellent option to use when needed. We were talking about maybe Bubba as the starting CF before we got Damon. These guts are all aging and hurt and need some rest and Bernie was a great option to have and he could be next year as well if both sides want it.
2006-09-14 17:14:02
168.   yankeemonkey
I have a feeling the winning streak will end at 5...again.
2006-09-14 17:15:23
169.   LI yankee
That was un-Jeter-esque
2006-09-14 17:15:38
170.   singledd
152 It's absoluely amazing how powerful the words "I'm sorry" are. If Papi has said "I'm a little frustrated about my health and the teams health, and I didn't intend to belittle Jeter in anyway"... this would mostly go away. There would still be reaction to his 'HRs and RBIs make an MVP' concept, but at least the put-down aspect of this might go away.

However, in the 'throwing teammates under the bus' category, in his 'apology', he stated he wanted to be square with the media and "not be like Ramirez". Poor schmuck.

2006-09-14 17:16:04
171.   randym77
Baldelli again. Snakes on a flippin' plane.
2006-09-14 17:16:09
172.   yankeemonkey
Argh! Not again!
2006-09-14 17:16:58
173.   yankeemonkey
Question: did something happen to Rasner again?
2006-09-14 17:18:02
174.   bobtaco
Baldelli vs Karstens looks like Arod vs Colon
2006-09-14 17:18:30
175.   JeremyM
Man, I forgot about Rasner, he's looked good in his 2 appearances.
2006-09-14 17:19:08
176.   randym77
Rasner's warming. He's alive after all.
2006-09-14 17:19:33
177.   LI yankee
173 You can't really blame Kaarstens. He was notified he was pitching an hour before the game.
2006-09-14 17:19:44
178.   yankeemonkey
173 Ahhh, thanks to YES for answering the question!
2006-09-14 17:20:07
179.   BklynBmr
168 I was just about to say 'not so fast' before Rocco B. got up again... But still, no excuses to tank this one from an offensive standpoint, however. Even with a half-Clipper lineup, there's enough firepower to overcome the Rays. I know this is meaningless, but I'd like to see 100 wins.
2006-09-14 17:21:55
180.   yankeemonkey
177 I'm not blaming him at all. I was just wondering why Torre put him in instead of Rasner...especially considering, as Kaat pointed out, Karstens might have just had his throwing session yesterday and thus may be tired. Ah well. Gotta appreciate the kid taking one for the team regardless. And he'd be fine if not for the freakin' Baldelli!
2006-09-14 17:23:24
181.   LI yankee
180 Maybe because he's coming off an injury and Kaarstens isn't. I have no clue otherwise.
2006-09-14 17:26:02
182.   C2Coke
The rain is coming down.
2006-09-14 17:26:19
183.   yankeemonkey
Go rain, go!

Twinkies will probably win tonight...I'm hoping for a massive 3-way tie in the Central, so they have to play a playoff game and beat the crud out of each other ;-)

2006-09-14 17:26:28
184.   C2Coke
Seriously, they are now worried that Matsui is going to steal a base?
2006-09-14 17:27:25
185.   yankeemonkey
2006-09-14 17:28:14
186.   BklynBmr
That's why they're the D-Rays...
2006-09-14 17:29:07
187.   BklynBmr
KT goes deep here...
2006-09-14 17:29:17
188.   yankeemonkey
Why not have KT bunt here? Torre makes Abreu bunt, but not him?
2006-09-14 17:30:08
189.   yankeemonkey
187 Or, you know, strikes out...Either or.
2006-09-14 17:30:09
190.   randym77
Can KT put down a bunt?
2006-09-14 17:30:56
191.   LI yankee
Bernie walks, Jeter hits a walk off grand slam in the 5th
2006-09-14 17:30:57
192.   yankeemonkey
O's staging a comeback, trying to help us shrink the magic number...
2006-09-14 17:31:35
193.   BklynBmr
189 Errr, I meant deep in the count ;-(
2006-09-14 17:31:54
194.   yankeemonkey
191 Or, you know, strike out.


2006-09-14 17:32:42
195.   yankeemonkey
C'mon Captain, our last hope!
2006-09-14 17:33:09
196.   randym77
Capt. Clutch comes through again.
2006-09-14 17:33:30
197.   BklynBmr
M. V. P.
2006-09-14 17:33:32
198.   C2Coke
195 And Cap'n Clutch always does it.
2006-09-14 17:33:42
199.   Simone
Wow, maybe clutch does exist. Yeah, Jeter.
2006-09-14 17:34:35
200.   yankeemonkey

Cap now tied with Mauer at .346.

Show/Hide Comments 201-250
2006-09-14 17:34:49
201.   David
Jeter and Mauer tied at .346. Mauer is 0 for 2.
2006-09-14 17:34:54
202.   BklynBmr
Cano can hit the walk-off here...
2006-09-14 17:35:35
203.   yankeemonkey
202 You're jinxing them!
2006-09-14 17:36:21
204.   C2Coke
202 How bad is the rain? Cano might give Arod the pleasure to hit a Grand Slam.
2006-09-14 17:36:26
205.   BklynBmr
Speed kills...
2006-09-14 17:36:30
206.   yankeemonkey
ALRIGHT Robby! Tie game!

202 Good job ;-)

2006-09-14 17:36:35
207.   Simone
Yeah, Robbie! Whew, I thought Carl had that one.
2006-09-14 17:36:36
208.   randym77
Yeah, Robbie!

But how did Crawford drop that?

2006-09-14 17:36:37
209.   LI yankee
2006-09-14 17:36:45
210.   Sumit
As of now, Jeter is leading by 0.0002
2006-09-14 17:37:25
211.   C2Coke
203 He jinxed Cano into a double rather than a HR.
2006-09-14 17:38:00
212.   BklynBmr
204 No way. Robbie is a greedy bast*rd ;-)
2006-09-14 17:38:08
213.   yankeemonkey
208 I don't think Crawford ever really had it...looked more like he took a swipe at it and just missed...
2006-09-14 17:38:17
214.   C2Coke
208 I bet the ball is more than a little slippery.
2006-09-14 17:39:10
215.   yankeemonkey
Ooooh...Karstens without his hat, no so pretty -_-
2006-09-14 17:39:22
216.   yankeemonkey
2006-09-14 17:39:56
217.   randym77
213 No, it was one he usually gets. If anything, he overran it. It bounced off the heel of his glove.

He may have been looking at the wall instead of at the ball.

2006-09-14 17:42:08
218.   yankz
Why does Morneau bat 5th, behind Michael "My OPS is 104 points lower" Cuddyer?
2006-09-14 17:42:48
219.   seamus
hmm. looks like i didn't miss a whole lot...
2006-09-14 17:43:16
220.   wsporter
216 "no so pretty" is good. Is pretty good. No?
2006-09-14 17:43:36
221.   yankz
Boston's losing...almost makes you feel bad for them. Wait, scratch that.
2006-09-14 17:43:55
222.   C2Coke
Now it's pouring.
2006-09-14 17:44:00
223.   Travis
Cano with RISP, pre-injury: .227, 23 RBI (17 for 75)
Cano with RISP, post-injury: .420, 37 RBI (21 for 50)
2006-09-14 17:44:16
224.   wsporter
How 'bout them O's. No so pretty bad. :-)
2006-09-14 17:44:32
225.   randym77
Man, the rain is looking pretty bad.
2006-09-14 17:44:49
226.   yankeemonkey
220 Is pretty ugly is what I meant, I guess ;-)
2006-09-14 17:46:31
227.   yankeemonkey
Hmm...they'll probably lose Rasner if there's a rain delay. Which will be annoying.
2006-09-14 17:47:24
228.   Travis
218 To split the lefties Mauer and Morneau.
2006-09-14 17:48:19
229.   yankeemonkey
Totally dry here on the UES...weird...Probably heading my way, the rain is.
2006-09-14 17:50:14
230.   LI yankee
223 Cano has had 37 RBIs with RISP in a month and a half? Wow.
2006-09-14 17:50:25
231.   marc
Good move by Torre not to subject Wong to this miserable weather and possible game delays.
2006-09-14 17:52:00
232.   yankeemonkey
Oh great, now the D-Ray pitcher has gone and hurt delays!!! Let's win this baby!
2006-09-14 17:52:01
233.   marc
Shields slipped on the mound and knee may be hurt
2006-09-14 17:52:20
234.   LI yankee
Convenient time to get cramps...
2006-09-14 17:53:04
235.   BklynBmr
Man, you could almost see whatever spasm or cramp Shields suffered in the replay of his last warmup pitch. That was wierd...
2006-09-14 17:53:17
236.   C2Coke
231 Which might have cut his start short as well. Torre wasn't going to waste Wang's start.
2006-09-14 17:54:06
237.   C2Coke
Now there's a delay?
2006-09-14 17:54:24
238.   yankeemonkey
Yah, good job by Torre.

Sooo....exit URP starter, enter URP reliever?

2006-09-14 17:54:56
239.   randym77
They've decided Cy Shields can't pitch any more.
2006-09-14 17:55:06
240.   yankeemonkey
237 Delay is because of the pitching change.
2006-09-14 17:55:39
241.   mehmattski
The answer to the word scramble is STILL Esteban Loaiza.
2006-09-14 17:56:15
242.   C2Coke
240 Yea, and the rain is better now.
2006-09-14 17:56:36
243.   Travis
241 No, it's "Estaban Loiaza."
2006-09-14 17:56:48
244.   singledd
This is silly to risk injury in a virtually meaningless game. Call the thing off.
2006-09-14 17:57:18
245.   yankeemonkey
241 ?

PH Wilson for Giambi!

2006-09-14 17:58:08
246.   C2Coke
244 It could end any minute now.
2006-09-14 17:59:06
247.   randym77
244 I have to agree. Much as I want to see baseball tonight, I don't want to see anyone hurt.
2006-09-14 18:00:54
248.   yankeemonkey
Yah, I don't see the point of this either. If this game is critical to the standings when the season ends and they need to, they can play it. Otherwise, why risk it?
2006-09-14 18:01:04
249.   marc
Suzyn just read the regulations and a tie game that is official is called a tie and has to be re-played in its entirety unless the league president decides it will have no bearing on things. Get some fukn runs please.
2006-09-14 18:02:02
250.   LI yankee
Is it supposed to rain through the night?
Show/Hide Comments 251-300
2006-09-14 18:03:05
251.   yankeemonkey
I believe so, yes. Unfortunately.
2006-09-14 18:03:17
252.   randym77
249 This game has no bearing on things...does it?
2006-09-14 18:04:14
253.   C2Coke
250 Likely until around midnight.
2006-09-14 18:04:20
254.   Travis
252 Only home field advantage, possibly.
2006-09-14 18:04:25
255.   LI yankee
So would this not extend Jeter's hit streak?
2006-09-14 18:05:29
256.   Travis
255 It would. It's an official game, and all the stats count, even if it ends in a tie.
2006-09-14 18:05:31
257.   Yankee Fan in Chicago
231 Shame Torre didn't think of that when he threw a 40 yr old with creaky knees and a bad back out in the teeming rain in game 3 last October.

(Tho everyone blames RJ for spitting the bit in that game, it was tough to ask him to pitch in those conditions. I knew at the time that he wouldn't be able to stride into his pitches, and would leave the ball up therefore.)

2006-09-14 18:05:38
258.   JeremyM
I think in a tie, the stats still count. I could be wrong.
2006-09-14 18:06:01
259.   marc
this forced pitcher change looking like a big boost to TB.
2006-09-14 18:06:09
260.   randym77
254 Forgot about that.
2006-09-14 18:06:11
261.   JeremyM
256 258 Or what Travis said.
2006-09-14 18:07:49
262.   mehmattski
245 On, they have a sequence of dumb things between innings, like promoting their online radio show, the Tom Petty album, their fantasy leagues. And at one point it has a word scramble: NETBSEA AZLAOI. Hint: He plays in the American League West.

And screw you, I am going to win my Fantasy League, I'm no liar! Ryan Howard, Bobby Abreu, Carlos Beltran and Justin Verlander have powered me to victory!

2006-09-14 18:08:14
263.   Travis
257 If the Yankees could have gotten a hit in Game 5 with RISP, RJ would be a Yankee hero right now for his (now forgotten) 4-1/3 shutout innings in relief on 2 days rest.
2006-09-14 18:08:23
264.   singledd
We're slowing replacing all the regulars to prevent injury. Where's effing Womack when we need him?
2006-09-14 18:09:12
265.   marc
I hope Rasner and Bruney both make the PS roster. Lidle I can do without.
2006-09-14 18:10:04
266.   yankz
Watch out, Nolan Ryan.
2006-09-14 18:10:05
267.   yankeemonkey
Hey, did they finally get Rocco "Ted Williams" Baldelli?
2006-09-14 18:10:11
268.   LI yankee
262 Yeah the commercials talk to you. Weird.
2006-09-14 18:10:25
269.   yankz
No, Teddy Ballgame is 3/3.
2006-09-14 18:10:38
270.   yankeemonkey
Whoops. Rocco up now. Eek.
2006-09-14 18:11:11
271.   LI yankee
265 Bruney will make it for sure barring injury, don't know about Rasner.
2006-09-14 18:11:28
272.   C2Coke
264 Remember there was also a guy named Siarra?
2006-09-14 18:11:35
273.   BklynBmr
Bernie would never have gotten to that...
2006-09-14 18:11:39
274.   yankz
Yahoo, Rocco's out!
2006-09-14 18:11:42
275.   randym77
That was close.
2006-09-14 18:11:52
276.   yankeemonkey
They DID get him! Yay!
2006-09-14 18:12:39
277.   neilymon
rasner just struck out 4/6 batters and retired the one d-ray who's been going off all night.

with all due respect to our man brian bruney, he's making a STRONG impression to make a last-ditch attempt at the PS roster.

btw. . .anyone else going to root for these d-rays next year? i feel like they can all get better together.

2006-09-14 18:12:54
278.   JeremyM
Rasner pitches in the rain like Gene Kelly sings in it, apparently. I'd like him to get some more looks before October.
2006-09-14 18:14:48
279.   randym77
273 Bernie looked like he didn't think he was getting to it. The expression on his face! :-D
2006-09-14 18:19:02
280.   yankz
Kevin Thompson has a .970 OPS in 23 AB this year. Small sample size, yeah yeah.
2006-09-14 18:19:14
281.   mehmattski
277 I'm with you, I've been watching these kids at Durham for a few years. I hope they spend more on quality pithcing and don't waste the prime years of Crawford and others. I'd be thrilled if they contended for the wild card next year. With the Yanks winning the division, of course.
2006-09-14 18:20:29
282.   BklynBmr
279 Exactly. My heart stopped for a second there, too '-)
2006-09-14 18:20:46
283.   JeremyM
Bernie, nice!
2006-09-14 18:21:06
284.   bobtaco
Nice KT, nice!
2006-09-14 18:21:20
285.   marc
gee that decrepit old man is useless
2006-09-14 18:21:32
286.   randym77
Man. Baldelli has an arm.
2006-09-14 18:24:44
287.   BklynBmr
A poor imitation of the Jeff Nelson move...
2006-09-14 18:25:47
288.   neilymon
281 Duh. And the Blue Jays can finish in third, and the Orioles can finish in fourth (or just be demoted to AAA, whatever).

Honestly, though, if the Devil Rays play the 2007 lineup that Cliff mentioned, and can get Jae Seo back to last year's form, they might be competitive with another one or two pitchers. Any thoughts on who's worth pursuing for our friends over in Tampa? Obviously no Zito for these guys. . .but what about someone like Jason Jennings?

2006-09-14 18:25:58
289.   yankz
F'n Shawn Camp, Captain could've had the lead.
2006-09-14 18:26:05
290.   JeremyM
Dammit. Come on Cano.
2006-09-14 18:26:21
291.   BklynBmr
That was way outside. Now we have to do it the hard way, but I'm thinking Robbie gets the job done...
2006-09-14 18:29:30
292.   Simone
Nice at bat by Robbie who is hitting everything.
2006-09-14 18:29:56
293.   C2Coke
Cano really is greedy fast.
2006-09-14 18:30:07
294.   BklynBmr
Rockin' Robbie! Good hustle, my man...
2006-09-14 18:30:38
295.   Travis
Cano has 11 RBI in the last 4 games.
2006-09-14 18:30:39
296.   JeremyM
All right, call the game, whether it's raining or not. Safety first.
2006-09-14 18:30:45
297.   wsporter
I remain convinced. ROBBY!!!!!!!
2006-09-14 18:31:32
298.   LI yankee
I think it's gonna be very apparent next year that Cano is not a #8 hitter.
2006-09-14 18:31:37
299.   mehmattski
I will look forward to seeing #22 retired at Robinson Cano Day at the new Yankee Stadium in 2022.
2006-09-14 18:31:37
300.   BklynBmr
May the skies now open in Biblical proportions...
Show/Hide Comments 301-350
2006-09-14 18:31:53
301.   yankz
Oh no he didn't
2006-09-14 18:32:53
302.   Simone
Good job, A-Rod. The crowd going crazy. Very nice.
2006-09-14 18:33:18
303.   BklynBmr
More useless RBI from Alex. I hate that guy ;-)
2006-09-14 18:33:20
304.   BklynBmr
More useless RBI from Alex. I hate that guy ;-)
2006-09-14 18:33:36
305.   mehmattski
Of course, A-Rod only gets RBIs in 7-4 games. All 112 of those RBIs are completely meaningless. What a stat padder.
2006-09-14 18:33:48
306.   Yankee Fan in Chicago
I don't want to jinx it, but I think Cano is going to have a monster year next year. I'm thinking avg over .325, 30 homers,100 rbis, ops near 1.000.
2006-09-14 18:34:10
307.   BklynBmr
[303-304] Sorry. Sorry.
2006-09-14 18:34:32
308.   C2Coke
Now they are awake. Looks like the rain is ok now too, but the wet field presents some dangers.
2006-09-14 18:34:48
309.   wsporter
299 I'll see you there.
2006-09-14 18:35:07
310.   RIYank
Oh yes he did!
Just tuning in, on the road so I can't watch. Except this is watching.

Here we go, Yankees, here we go!

2006-09-14 18:35:20
311.   AbbyNormal821
30 & nice you had to say it twice???
301...oh yes he did!!!

a comeback lead AND Boston is losing to Baltimore again (as of right now). Pretty good night in my book!

2006-09-14 18:35:44
312.   AbbyNormal821
...i meant 301...not 30
2006-09-14 18:35:52
313.   LI yankee
306 He may be at that level right now (since the injury anyways)
2006-09-14 18:35:54
314.   neilymon
You know, even if A-Rod were somehow physically only capable of driving 'em in when the Yanks were already ahead, that'd still be incredibly useful. Just bat him 5th or 6th, let Giambi or Matsui (or CANO, apparently; yikes) get a one-run lead and then apparently A-Rod will blow it open.

"Padding the stats", eh? I mean, I'll take it.

2006-09-14 18:36:10
315.   RIYank
306 I agree.
Does anyone know what the numbers are for typical increase in batting production for a guy Cano's age? I think it's gotta be huge. On average.
2006-09-14 18:36:22
316.   mehmattski
311 Boston has a baseball team?
2006-09-14 18:37:29
317.   RIYank
Whoa, just noticed: Rasner is looking good, huh?
2006-09-14 18:37:42
318.   Yankee Fan in Chicago
316 Yeah, I thought the Braves had left Boston and moved to Milwaukee!
2006-09-14 18:38:15
319.   RIYank
316 Technically it's Pawtucket, but they call them 'Boston'.
2006-09-14 18:38:52
320.   JeremyM
Old friend James Hoey in for Baltimore to blow it versus the Sox.
2006-09-14 18:39:36
321.   wsporter
Lets go Melky, little hit baby!!!!!!
2006-09-14 18:39:42
322.   RIYank
Uh oh.
What happened to Jorgie???
2006-09-14 18:40:08
323.   singledd
Mauer still 0-2 w/2 BBs - leads Derek in OBP by 11 pts.
2006-09-14 18:40:13
324.   mehmattski
315 I'm really interested for the PECOTA comparisons after this season, but has the list of most similar players at Age 22. Some highlights:

Fred Dunlap
Tony Lazzeri
Paul Molitor
Billy Herman

Those last three are HOFers...

2006-09-14 18:40:24
325.   randym77
And Melky ends up having to work even on his day off.
2006-09-14 18:41:34
326.   singledd
325 and a lot of work it was.
2006-09-14 18:41:37
327.   Simone
322 Jorgie got hit on the elbow and couldn't shake it off.
2006-09-14 18:41:52
328.   wsporter
322 Hit on the elbow, big time owie.
2006-09-14 18:43:00
329.   RIYank
How did he get hit? Did he actually foul it off his elbow? I guess he must have.

324 Ah, thanks. Very interesting. I'll take Tony Lazzeri, thank you very much.

2006-09-14 18:43:24
330.   Travis
324 I'd take a Fred Dunlap 1884-type performance from Cano. Who cares that it came in a AA quality league?

2006-09-14 18:43:43
331.   David
Is there any word on when Sheffield is likely to be activated?
2006-09-14 18:43:58
332.   singledd
Dye leads Ortiz in OPS by a few points, but Manny leads 'em both by 25 points. How come Manny isn't even mentioned in the MVP discussion, when Ortiz is in the middle of it?
2006-09-14 18:45:39
333.   RIYank
Thank you, Travis, you saved me from a "Who is Fred Dunlap?"

332 You have to ask that question? You don't live in New England. Ortiz is the hearthrob; Manny is his supporting cast.

2006-09-14 18:47:27
334.   randym77
329 No. Though A-Rod thought it was a HBP and went to 2B. The umpire told him to get back to 1B.

Jorgie swung at the pitch, missed with the bat...but didn't miss with his back elbow.

2006-09-14 18:47:56
335.   RIYank
I vote for a moratorium on triples. (Until the Tampa outfield leaves town.)

Very nice, big K for Rasner, though. And he gets TyWig, too.

2006-09-14 18:48:45
336.   RIYank
334 Ouch.
I'm yammering. (Just trying to make up for lost time.)
2006-09-14 18:49:40
337.   wsporter
Is everybody loving Rasner at this point. I saw him pitch for the Nats last year and can't believe they gave up on him. He reminded me of Eddie Figueroa then and he still does. He and Bruney are great pick ups. Ca$hman is the man.
2006-09-14 18:51:03
338.   pistolpete
337 Well, he's doing well against Tampa - I'd like to see him a few more times down the stretch before I pass judgment.
2006-09-14 18:51:03
339.   pistolpete
337 Well, he's doing well against Tampa - I'd like to see him a few more times down the stretch before I pass judgment.
2006-09-14 18:52:06
340.   pistolpete
Ack! Double post!
2006-09-14 18:53:06
341.   singledd
333 I live in New Hampshire. Since Manny is Manny, it's good to have a good guy like Ortiz to worship. But everybody knows Manny is a better hitter. If Manny batted in front or Ortiz, the numbers would be even more swayed.
2006-09-14 18:53:39
342.   singledd
341 Not to mention that Manny is NOT a DH.
2006-09-14 18:54:03
343.   Sumit
Mauer next up in Cleveland. Let's hope he makes an out. That way cap'n will be up by a fraction.
2006-09-14 18:54:33
344.   RIYank
341 Now I get it: you were asking a rhetorical question! (I know, really, you meant: is there any good reason for Ortiz to be getting all the love and Manny just an afterthought.)
2006-09-14 18:54:47
345.   wsporter
339 pistol, that little number he did on the tTinkies was imporessive. This guy is the goods.
2006-09-14 18:55:33
346.   Chyll Will
333 Wow, didn't he just get out of the hospital for that?
2006-09-14 18:56:17
347.   wsporter
345 tTinkes = Twinkies. Don't ask me how but it does. Oh My.
2006-09-14 18:56:29
348.   LI yankee
Our magic number will be 6, and this could be the first 6 game winning streak in '06
2006-09-14 18:56:36
349.   mehmattski
330 Dunlap only had 29 walks in that season. Clearly he's not patient enough at the plate. I just included him since he was first on the comparison. It would be weird if there were PECOTA comparisons for other professions, and they had a website that showed me that the most comparable scientist to me at age 22 had been dead for 115 years...
2006-09-14 18:56:39
350.   RIYank
346 Ooooh.
Yeah, bad choice of words.
Show/Hide Comments 351-400
2006-09-14 18:56:45
351.   Travis
346 Very nice.
2006-09-14 18:58:49
352.   zgveritas
I'm getting sick of Clifford Shwyer the mountain climber & Mt. Sinai hospital.

Love these Yankees though!

2006-09-14 18:58:59
353.   Yankee Fan in Chicago
With apologies to Eric B: Rasner for President.
2006-09-14 18:59:11
354.   Travis
349 I know you're being sarcastic, but Dunlap's 29 walks in the 1884 Union Association were the 3rd most in the league. The UA leaderboard is ridiculous:

2006-09-14 18:59:16
355.   mehmattski
Here we are nearing the end of Jim Kaat's broadcasting career. Despite the announcer bashing at the beginning of this thread, I thought I'd bring that up again. Love him or hate him (or indifferent him), he was around for a long time, and he is to be respected. Good luck in whatever you're doing next, Kitty. Tip of my hat to you, sir.
2006-09-14 18:59:18
356.   pistolpete
347 I'm just always a little wary of castoffs. He could just be this year's Chacon. And we all know how that fairy tale ended.
2006-09-14 18:59:37
357.   RIYank
Lefty Juan Lara in to face Mauer. Got 'im!
2006-09-14 19:00:55
358.   randym77
I know it's probably too soon to be thinking such things, but I'd rather have Rasner than Lidle. Or even Wright or Villone.
2006-09-14 19:01:19
359.   seamus
mauer just flew out.

Jeter .346
Mauer .345

2006-09-14 19:01:21
360.   RIYank
Mmmm, a good night all around. Maybe not for Karsten's, I guess.
2006-09-14 19:01:27
361.   AbbyNormal821
Nice, 3 hour go home guys and rest of for your weekend beatdown on Boston!
2006-09-14 19:01:34
362.   Sumit
Doubleplusgood news: Mauer lines out in Cleveland. As of now, Cap'n leads the batting title race. If, that's a big if, Indians retire the side in order he will not bat again tonight.
2006-09-14 19:01:40
363.   LI yankee
Jeter is up on Mauer by .00033
2006-09-14 19:02:01
364.   JeremyM
356 I don't know, Rasner is young and he actually strikes guys out and doesn't walk them- at least so far!
2006-09-14 19:02:03
365.   seamus
359 to add, because he probably will qualify by the end of the year...

Jeter .346
Mauer .345
Cano .339

2006-09-14 19:02:20
366.   Yankee Fan in Chicago
356 Chacon's peripherals were always pretty poor. That's why he was the Jedi master. Rasner's look pretty good so far.
2006-09-14 19:04:11
367.   LI yankee
I think this is the first time Jeter ends the game with the better average. He's passed Mauer mid-game before.
2006-09-14 19:04:34
368.   pistolpete
366 I hear ya, but it might be too late in the season for him to be considered for the post. Too bad, because he seems like he would be an ideal long man to come in for either Lidle or Wright...
2006-09-14 19:04:53
369.   The Bear
Lets Go O's.... HOLD THE LEAD!!
2006-09-14 19:05:04
370.   Sliced Bread
Scanning the comments, didn't see more than a word or two re: Bernie's hit-and-run single, which sent the go-ahead runner to third.

It wasn't a home run, but that worked out okay, right?

Props to Bernie and Joe.

2006-09-14 19:06:11
371.   RIYank
I think the Twinks need three baserunners over the last two innings for Mauer to bat. His out ended their half of the seventh.
2006-09-14 19:06:27
372.   wsporter
356 Your right he could be but I don't think so. He's younger and has better stuff. Besides if he gives us what Chacon gave us last year I'll worry about next year when it happens.

The Nats let him go because they thought they had roster issues. They did have issues but they let the wrong guy go. If he gets the shot I think he'll do the job.

2006-09-14 19:08:25
373.   Travis
Boston just tied it with a couple of bloops.
2006-09-14 19:08:57
374.   BklynBmr
5-5 in Baltimore, top 8 — 2 on, 1 out. Papi up...
2006-09-14 19:09:31
375.   randym77
I don't envy Joe the job of having to pick a postseason roster out of this bunch. Some tough decisions looming.
2006-09-14 19:12:10
376.   BklynBmr
375 A good problem to have, given the lack of bench depth in the last few post seasons. But, yeah, it's going to be very interesting to see how it shakes out...
2006-09-14 19:13:14
377.   wsporter
Lets hope Jorge is OK.
2006-09-14 19:14:16
378.   Travis
Pena and Lowell, like all Sox hitters not named Ortiz or Manny, come up unclutch. Still 5-5, middle of the 8th.
2006-09-14 19:14:36
379.   BklynBmr
After Papi walked to load the bags, Lowell lines out to Roberts at second. 5-5.
2006-09-14 19:15:13
380.   yankeemonkey
Wow, John Flaherty's got a serious case of ears...
2006-09-14 19:15:50
381.   LI yankee
Wang and Beckett tomorrow

Two 26 year olds. One getting paid 4.5 million and has an ERA over 5, the other getting paid 350K and is 17-5.

2006-09-14 19:17:44
382.   Chyll Will
380 Probably nothing he hasn't heard before...
2006-09-14 19:17:53
383.   yankeemonkey
We've got a 6-game win streak!!! Woohoo!

::happy dance::

2006-09-14 19:17:58
384.   wsporter
Bananas is a very funny movie.
2006-09-14 19:18:33
385.   yankeemonkey
382 Niiiiice!
2006-09-14 19:19:49
386.   C2Coke
383 The last time we had a 6-game streak was exactly a year ago.
2006-09-14 19:19:50
387.   BklynBmr
381 Gotta give those small market, low payroll teams their just due for superior scouting and exceptional development of minor leaguers... Wish we had those qualities going for us. We just buy everything. Hopefully that will change.
2006-09-14 19:19:58
388.   LI yankee
A walkoff homer by Kevin Millar would hit the spot right now
2006-09-14 19:20:55
389.   mehmattski
370 Well, there was 285 which was spoken in all good natured sarcasm, I'd imagine. For the most part, I agree with you re: Bernie. I said some hot headed things here back in July/August when this team was struggling for the division lead, and I regret them. Bernie has been one of my favorite players of all time. I have no problem with him playing every day in some capacity from now until the end of the regular season. That said, I really, really hope he hangs it up after this season, and I wish he would announce his retirement in the next couple of weeks, so that Stadium fans can properly congratulate him. As great a player he has been, he is clearly not what he once was, and it would be the shame of shames to see him get cut in Spring Training next year, or something like that.

My next choice would be for him to fulfill his need to play baseball with another franchise. It didn't sully the reputation of Tino Martinez in the Bronx, and I don't think anyone would hold it against him. Then maybe he can come back and sign a ST contract with the Yanks and retire, like the 49ers did with Jerry Rice. I guess what I'm trying to say is that I hope the end of Bernie's career is blessed with as much grace as he showed in his prime, in covering centerfield at Yankee Stadium.

2006-09-14 19:21:01
390.   pistolpete
388 In the 8th?
2006-09-14 19:21:25
391.   yankeemonkey
388 Let's not get greedy....a bases-loaded double would work just as well.
2006-09-14 19:22:01
392.   LI yankee
390 He's due up in the 10th, if it gets that far.
2006-09-14 19:23:26
393.   RIYank
390 Only Papi can do that.

Looks like Mauer gets another shot after all. Twinks are smacking it in the eighth.

2006-09-14 19:25:21
394.   Travis
Rodrigo Lopez in to pitch the 9th for the O's. To their credit, Chris Ray pitched the crucial 8th, and I guess they have no one better in their pen.
2006-09-14 19:29:35
395.   Travis
Lopez walks the first 2 batters, but stays in the game.
2006-09-14 19:29:53
396.   yankeemonkey
ESPN2 has the Boston game as bonus coverage. Looks like O's are doing their best to blow it. Pathetic.
2006-09-14 19:31:15
397.   RIYank
Rodrigo Lopez is not a good pitcher. (He had some trouble throwing strikes, let's just say.)
2006-09-14 19:31:18
398.   wsporter
Ortiz is the best defensive DH in the League hands down. Case closed. I can't count the number of runs he saves every game. A true stud muffin in every sense of the term.
2006-09-14 19:31:36
399.   LI yankee
Pedroia is batting well below the Mendoza line at .122

How good was this guy supposed to be?

2006-09-14 19:31:39
400.   Travis
Why in the world would you intentionally walk Alex Cora under any circumstances with the top of the order coming up?
Show/Hide Comments 401-450
2006-09-14 19:32:19
401.   RIYank
396 Hey, thanks! Owe you one for that.
2006-09-14 19:33:02
402.   yankz
Mauer up
2006-09-14 19:33:08
403.   RIYank
Mauer to the plate...
2006-09-14 19:33:49
404.   yankeemonkey
401 No problem. Although I can't guarantee that you'll like the ending of this one :)

Camden Yards has a serious RSN infestation problem, doesn't it....

2006-09-14 19:34:01
405.   yankz
Fuck, Mauer takes the lead back
2006-09-14 19:34:06
406.   RIYank
Mauer singles!
Hats off.
2006-09-14 19:34:18
407.   pistolpete
Jeez, thank God football season started, huh?

I mean, the Red Sox started sucking and ESPN had nothing to lead off SportsCenter for a good 2-3 weeks there...

2006-09-14 19:34:32
408.   RIYank
2006-09-14 19:34:34
409.   LI yankee
367 D'oh!
2006-09-14 19:34:36
410.   yankeemonkey
Argh! Mauer singles to up his BA to .347
2006-09-14 19:35:21
411.   yankeemonkey
Feckin' Loretta....
2006-09-14 19:35:52
412.   RIYank
Rodrigo Lopez is not a good pitcher.
Ah, of course. ESPN2 is all done now. Schmucks.

Well, no matter. Either way (Sox W or L), we clinch by taking three of four, and not by splitting. So.

2006-09-14 19:36:08
413.   AbbyNormal821
411 Amen to that - he's a fargin' icehole!
2006-09-14 19:36:36
414.   yankeemonkey
Whaaaaaa....? They're cutting off the game to show effing' Quite Frankly?

Whatever happend to (N)ESPN?

2006-09-14 19:37:37
415.   RIYank
Jetes ought to fatten up on Sawx pitching this weekend, though. Who do the Twins have?
2006-09-14 19:38:33
416.   Travis
Bruce Chen in for the O's. Has there ever been a worse 9th inning, tie game righty-lefty combo than Lopez and Chen?
2006-09-14 19:39:11
417.   yankeemonkey
415 Lousy Tribe pitching, I'm afraid....Carmona (Eek!), Sabathia and Byrd are scheduled.
2006-09-14 19:39:48
418.   yankeemonkey
416 Tim Redding and Sean Henn?
2006-09-14 19:40:29
419.   JeremyM
Twins will be just a game back from Detroit if they hold on.

Having Chen versus Ortiz is like throwing rocks at a man with a machine gun, to quote Rowdy Piper.

2006-09-14 19:40:43
420.   RIYank
416 And yet, Papi fails. Funny game.
417 Dang. Maybe Mauer gets the day off against Carmona?
2006-09-14 19:40:58
421.   Ron Burgundy
Meh. Sawx can still blow this. Their bullpen has been quite impressive this year.
2006-09-14 19:41:03
422.   Travis
Mr. MVP with the pop up, but it doesn't matter, because the Sox are up 1 and Mr. Zero himself, Mike Timlin, is coming in to close.
2006-09-14 19:41:35
423.   RIYank
Heck, if Papi had Matsui and Cano in his line-up, he would have doubled.
2006-09-14 19:41:41
424.   wsporter
Ka-lutch. Papi is soooooo Ka-lutch. Classic Ka-lutch.
2006-09-14 19:41:56
425.   yankeemonkey
Why not leave Foulke in to close?
2006-09-14 19:42:23
426.   Travis
416 Even Joe Torre wouldn't use Redding and Henn in a tie game on the road. Jeff Weaver, on the other hand ...
2006-09-14 19:42:34
427.   RIYank
"Quite Frankly", what a show.
"If Liriano comes back, the Yanks have absolutely no chance to beat the Twins in the playoffs."
Baseball genius.
2006-09-14 19:43:59
428.   yankeemonkey
427 OMG, seriously he said that?!
2006-09-14 19:44:24
429.   RIYank
Yeah, Smith did.
2006-09-14 19:44:45
430.   Travis
Kapler misreads a Mora ball over his head; leadoff double.

427 Stephen A. Smith is the man who thought a team could miss a field goal on 3rd down and get the ball back.

2006-09-14 19:44:57
431.   yankeemonkey
Mora, Markakis, Tejada up for the O's. There's still hope...
2006-09-14 19:45:06
432.   pistolpete
Mora doubles. Hang on to your hats, kids.
2006-09-14 19:45:08
433.   RIYank
Mike Timlin doing his thing! (Mora doubles, but I figure everyone still here is tracking it.)
2006-09-14 19:45:24
434.   Travis
Mora tags up on a short fly to center, off-line throw by Kapler to 3rd.
2006-09-14 19:45:46
435.   pistolpete
429 Wait, Smith said that tonight?
2006-09-14 19:45:59
436.   yankeemonkey
And right on cue, Mora double. Well done.
2006-09-14 19:46:00
437.   Travis
IBB to Tejada.
2006-09-14 19:46:16
438.   RIYank
430 How are you following the Boston game? Cool.
Huh, so Smith's talents extend beyond baseball.
2006-09-14 19:46:41
439.   pistolpete
C'mon, Ramon - keep the ball in the air.
2006-09-14 19:46:48
440.   RIYank
At least that makes some sense, walking Tejada. Here's hoping it bites them in the butt, though.
2006-09-14 19:46:51
441.   LI yankee
Tejada IBB...hmmmm look who's on deck
2006-09-14 19:47:12
442.   yankz
Hernandez owes us
2006-09-14 19:47:36
443.   yankeemonkey
Walkoff slam by heard it here first!
2006-09-14 19:47:39
444.   Travis
438 I live in D.C., so I get the game on my local cable channel.
2006-09-14 19:48:18
445.   Travis
Ugh, easy DP ball by Hernandez, game over.
2006-09-14 19:48:18
446.   yankeemonkey
438 "Talents" is being used loosely there, I hope.
2006-09-14 19:48:53
447.   yankeemonkey

Stupid Angelos.

2006-09-14 19:48:54
448.   RIYank
Nice try, LI yankee.
2006-09-14 19:49:11
449.   wsporter
438 MLB TV & Comcast Sports

O's blow

2006-09-14 19:49:30
450.   pistolpete
CRIPES. Oh well, we still would have had to beat Boston 3 times to clinch anyway...
Show/Hide Comments 451-500
2006-09-14 19:49:38
451.   Ron Burgundy
I HATE Tejada and Hernandez. They KILL us, but turn into crap against the Sawx.
2006-09-14 19:49:47
452.   LI yankee
447 Deadspin reader?
2006-09-14 19:50:34
453.   yankeemonkey
452 First thing every morning!
2006-09-14 19:51:01
454.   wsporter
444 Sage Steel is definately worth missing.
2006-09-14 19:51:04
455.   yankeemonkey
To be fair, Tejada got an IBB, not much he could've done there...
2006-09-14 19:51:22
456.   Travis
Hernandez took huge cuts at the first two pitches and fouled them off. Not great hitting, when a weak fly to any of those outfielders ties the game.
2006-09-14 19:52:01
457.   RIYank
446 Loosely, or ironically, take your pick.

Well, we couldn't get any help tonight, but the pinstripes did their job. The real fun is coming up soon.
Have a GOOD night.

2006-09-14 19:52:28
458.   JeremyM
No biggie, but I wouldn't finishing the job this weekend.
2006-09-14 19:54:40
459.   yankz
God how badly I want another sweep.
2006-09-14 19:55:28
460.   yankeemonkey
A good night all around, despite the O's continued suckage.

'night, y'all!

2006-09-14 19:59:27
461.   zgveritas
If the Yanks minor league squad only take one game versus Boston I hope they get Wang the win so he can get to 20 quickly.

Wonder if Manny will play this series? The last time he played was on Sept. 9th.

2006-09-14 20:01:27
462.   yankeemonkey
461 I'm pretty sure I heard somewhere today that it's unlikely he'll play.
2006-09-14 20:02:22
463.   wsporter
Hope we get it in manana. It would be great to finish things this weekend. A good night and good thoughts to all.
2006-09-14 20:22:19
464.   Zack
So Peter Abraham and Steve Lombardi are running questions on nicknames for Phil Hughes. Steve suggested Orange Crush. Meh. I suggested "The Avaitor" or just "avaitor." Might as well start up the discussion here too...Shoot away...
2006-09-14 20:31:36
465.   yankz
"The Chosen One"
2006-09-14 20:56:49
466.   BklynBmr
"The One" — inspired by yankz, of course ;-)
2006-09-15 00:06:24
467.   3rd gen yankee fan
153 Thanks again for all the info.

157 Damn, and all the time I lived in Cincy, I had no idea there was fun stuff in Columbus.

2006-09-15 05:34:35
468.   wsporter
467 re:157 I don't want to get too carried away; one can pee almost anywhere and that was the best part of the stop!

Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.