Baseball Toaster was unplugged on February 4, 2009.
One of the best stories in baseball in recent years was the trio of AL Central Titles won by the Minnesota Twins immediately after Commissioner Bud Selig threatened the team with contraction. Unfortunately, that story does not have a happy ending as, while we have all been waiting around for the Twins to convert their seemingly endless supply of young talent into a more meaningful title, the team has regressed into mediocrity. That the left side of their infield is populated by Juan Castro and Tony Batista, the latter of whom spent 2005 playing in Japan, should be evidence enough of that.
That said, the Twins are always going to be dangerous because of their pitching, which is why it's fortuitous that the Yankees are catching them this early in the season. One game shy of two times through their rotation, the Twins starters have a combined ERA of 6.63 and would-be two-time Cy Young winner Johan Santana, who will go tomorrow against Jaret Wright's first start of the season, has yet to win a game.
Tonight, the Yankees face 24-year-old rookie Scott Baker, who beat out Francisco Liriano (the left-handed future star who is generally considered the second coming of Santana) for the fifth starter's spot in spring training. While no pushover himself, Baker took the loss in his first start, allowing three runs on nine hits and a walk in 4 1/3 innings against the powerful Indians' lineup. A decent first outing spoiled by the fact that the Twins bats couldn't muster a single run against Jason Johnson, Gullermo Mota and Bob Wickman.
Mike Mussina takes the hill for the Yanks, looking to build upon his surprisingly strong performance in his first two starts.
2005 Record: 83-79 (.512)
2005 Pythagorean Record: 84-78 (.519)
Manager: Ron Gardenhire
General Manager: Terry Ryan
Home Ballpark (2005 Park Factors): Hubert H. Humphrey Metrodome (101/101)
Who's Replacing Whom?
Current Roster
1B Justin Morneau (L)
2B Luis Castillo (S)
SS Juan Castro (R)
3B Tony Batista (R)
C Joe Mauer (L)
RF Jason Kubel (L)
CF Torii Hunter (R)
LF Shannon Stewart (R)
DH Rondell White (R)
Bench:
R Michael Cuddyer (UT)
R Lew Ford (OF)
S Luis O. Rodriguez (IF)
S Nick Punto (IF)
R Mike Redmond (C)
Rotation:
L Johan Santana
R Brad Radke
R Carlos Silva
R Kyle Lohse
R Scott Baker
Bullpen:
R Joe Nathan
R Jesse Crain
R Juan Rincon
L Francisco Liroano
R Matt Guerrier
R Willie Eyre
DL: L Dave Gassner
Typical Lineup
R Shannon Stewart (LF)
S Luis Castillo (2B)
L Joe Mauer (C)
R Rondell White (DH)
R Torii Hunter (CF)
L Justin Morneau (1B)
R Tony Batista (3B)
L Jason Kubel (RF)
R Juan Castro (SS)
Let's go Yanks!
Hopefully it's just one bad inning...
This is where the Yanks need to break it open. C'mon Robbie!
Man, this Ump is really inconsistent on the high strike...
Heads up baserunning, Jorgie!
Think I'll let that straight line go by uncommented.
Why don't those morons move when they see the trajectory of the ball?
That play wasn't even close!
I have the local Min. feed and it didn't even look close on the one replay I got.
And it gives Gary "Frank Thomas" Sheffield exactly what he wants, less time playing both sides of the ball.
Was there just a "Yankees suck" chant going through the Metrodome? WTF?!?! I thought Twins fans were laid back, polite types??
I mean seriously, MLB goes on and on about how long it takes to become a MLB Ump. The time entailed and the training blah blah blah.
90% of the time they are better than any other sport, I will certainly give them that.
However, is it so much to ask to look the f**k up and see what angle the ball is taking to the plate? Was he hired from the NFL or what!
Nope, Minnestota fans are pussies, they wait for the lead before they chant.
Steiner moved out here to LA. I don't know about you, but I think he should have been given Kaye's job.
Ohhh, sweet fielding by Cano right there!
Have you seen the Christian freaks all over the airwaves, politics, and within the FCC? Of course they got complaints. The USA, where 10% are bible thumping morons perverting its actual teachings, and making the rules for the rest of us.
Why doesn't Jorge just let one go through! Where is Ty Cobb to talk to his catcher and teach an Ump a lesson when one is due?
Good defense and solid pitching. A very simple recipe to beat the Yankees.
I also wonder how the ESPN radio people missed it, 'cause Kay is equally terrible on his radio show.
And now it sounds like someone from the crowd is yelling "BALCO! Steroids!" I am very surprised.
Bklyn,
It's hard for anyone to stay interested in that dark crap hole the Twins play in.
Just like RJ's second start.
Oh Jorge! You were right there, nice try, ugg.
Moose is spent. I hope Tanyon doesn't have to come in with the bases loaded.
No retractable roof, no outside stadium with natural grass, no place in baseball!
This is the city that built a dome for football, taking away the only home field advantage they had. Aye you Fargo watching pork belly sellinh, co-op shopping, khaki and polo wearing, freaks!
Lord Farnswacker needs to get over this "I only pitch one inning, I hate to go in and then come out and then go back out" BS.
As my dad just said, "Son of a *!"
If they can't beat this snot nosed kid, how are they supposed to beat any White Sox or Red Sox or Oakland starter come playoff time.
I'm going to be sick.
When did that happen?!?
Maybe I am being hard on them. I just hate to see a wasted start. Especially considering that we don't know how many quality starts this staff will post this year. The Yanks will have to hit a good pitcher eventually, no?
And no, Bartolo Colon doesn't count.
Thank you, Robbie. Hope Sturtze doesn't come out to pitch the 8th.
Not that it would ever happen, but this is where Phillips ought to be pinch-hitting for GOB. Then Bubba could play RF in the 8th and 9th.
I'd use him right away. Give the kid a shot.
I do not believe anyone has worn it. It is a little odd. It could be George. Players and coaches who leave seem to find their numbers out there pretty quickly.
Joe won't bunt when we should. He has not clue 1 since Zim left. Bash Bash Bash. Lose Lose Lose.
Stormer, I wonder if 30 would have been available if Willie went to the Brewers rather than the Mets.
I do recall that they gave #31 to a back-up catcher something like the day after they traded Winfield. Brian Dorsett. That burned me bad.
Joe, the anti-Ozzie.
LOL. I would have to say the Winfield situation had umm, ahh, a slightly higher level of emotion involved. I'm pretty sure Goeorge would have sold Dave to Tyler Chicken if he could have.
George likes loyalty. I think #30 was coming out, one way or the other. Hopefully we'll see Willy in October.
It just proves what I've thought all along. Joe has no clue what he is doing. No Zim, no Willie, no clue!
I guess he hasn't looked around the league to check out what type of teams have been winning lately.
The White Sox didn't have 1 single player other than Konerko who is more than a little above average. However, frustrating the other team with bunts and steals, and squeezes helps change the game.
I love Joe, but if we could get someone with true baseball managing smarts, time to let the man go.
Yankee fans did that? I thought most fans understood who decides what cap you wear.
Seriously, what the hell! What on Gods green earth are they doing in Anaheim? How can we and most everyone else be so bad in the bullpen, and they just keep chugging along?
139 Until the past year or so, the player chose, but any Yankee fan worth his or her salt would know why Winfield chose Sand Diego.
Not just home runs. The Sox spread the HR's all over the lineup.
It's not just about actual runs scored or SB's. It's about pressuring the other team and making them make mistakes. It is about hitting Hr's AND running the bases well, stealing and bunting.
You cannot win simply bashing the ball and moving one base at a time, letting the opposing pitcher plop a comfy chair out there and relax.
Winfield didn't "choose" San Diego. The Hall decides.
Well if you hire a PI to dig up and plant shit on me, I'd stop coming to Bronx Banter.
Top 9: 4 runs? No problem, right?
That's also why the Twins are winning today. Scott Baker was outstanding.
08/20/2004 12:00 AM ET
Box >
Yanks gut out win over Twins
Bombers storm back in ninth after bullpen falters
By Mark Feinsand / MLB.com
Gary Sheffield's solo shot off Joe Nathan tied the score at 10 in the ninth inning. (Jim Mone/AP)
Own a download of this game
MINNEAPOLIS -- With a six-run lead in the seventh inning, the Yankees seemed destined to avert a three-game sweep at the hands of the Twins.
It turned out to be much more difficult than expected.
Minnesota rallied for seven runs in the seventh and eighth, but New York got the final word, tagging unhittable Twins closer Joe Nathan for four runs in the ninth en route to a 13-10 victory.
I had never met the man but always liked him. I was out here at an Angel-Yankee game and happened to run into him in the concourse all alone during BP. He stopped and talked with me for almost fifteen minutes. I was pretty young when he played and it's tough to judge a man after fifteen minutes of conversation in 2004, but he really seemed like a genuinely good man.
156 I agree about the defense and pitching, of course. However I stick by my assertion that you must bunt, steal and threaten the sqeeze to win consistently. When you face pitching like we did today, you cannot win any other way. Until the Yankees do this, when they are in close games at least, they won't make it very far in the playoffs. It's not about how often you do it, it's when you do it and it which games you do it. Joe proved tonight that although we were getting schooled at the plate, that when he had chances to bunt and try to get a run across, he still believed we could bash the ball, even though we hadn't all game long.
The more I think about it. The pitching was outstanding, but, if Jorge is called safe and Joe puts on bunt, a couple hit and runs, we could have tied the game. However Joe's the same manager he was in NYM and STL without Zim and Willie. He's gotta change or we wont be able to compete against solid defensive teams with 2 or more solid starters, and that includes every playoff team.
I'll read it. Thanks! No hard feelings man. I just hate watching this brand of baseball. In my mind, its not even baseball.
I Read it. It's interesting. Although we have no chance of improving either our pitching or defense this year. Buckle up!
I'm in LA suffering through our 3rd, count them 3rd rain delay or PPD of the year. Sf and ANA have had like 4 already. To those who dispute weather and climate change, welcome to rainy California 50+ inches last year and near 30+ already this year. Guess it's time to move back to NY.
Don't forget lousy defense and starting pitching.
Again, Joe has no idea what he is doing without Willie or Zim. Sure, it's a who's who on the coaching bench, but that doesn't mean they know what they're doing, simply because they were great players.
And as for Willie being Joe's brain, you're talking about someone who has insisted for the last 170 games on hitting someone with a .305 obp leadoff. Jeez.
Wow. Seriously, If I am being compared to Joe Morgan, I must seriously rethink my argument.
However, I stick by part of it. Athough more "half-assed hit and runs" as you so colorfully called them, may not be the answer, they are the right thing to do, and certaily, wouldn't hurt the teams chances.
I'm just throwing it out there.
With all due respect, that borders on the absurd. If you want to suggest that Anaheim is a superior team, I'll bite. They have won the World Series more recently than us and have knocked us out of the playoffs twice. Plus, they are the only team with a winning record against us in the Torre era. They lost 2 out of 3 to Seattle before facing us, and have since gone on to lose games to Texas and Baltimore.
Oakland is at best playing on level ground with the Yankees. Their pitching is very good and they have some decent players in their every day lineup, but they were just swept by the Twins and lost their first to Texas.
Minnesota opened the season by dropping 2 out of 3 to Toronto and were then swept by Cleveland.
If you want to suggest that we're being beaten by better teams, then you would have to stretch that to further include Seattle, Texas, Toronto, and Cleveland who have showed some measure of mastery over the teams we've been losing to.
We're losing because we are a one dimensional team. We club home runs and we pitch to a middle of the road level. When we don't go out and crush bombs, the so-so pitching is exposed. When we hit, no one can beat us. We'll still win 90+ this season but a lot of nights we'll be frustrated with the lack of diversity we have in our arsenal.
Our pitching (surprisingly) so far has been very good. We are near the top of the league in pitching.
We had only 2 walks, and gave up four. When you're not hitting, you must work for walks and tire the (good) pitcher. This is how we beat Pedro consistantly. We were NOT very patient at the plate last night.
And I remember a day when Bernie waited for a pitch to drive... instead of pounding them in the dirt. Not so GOB.
And while I agree that Joe is a poor and conservative stratigist (sp?), my little sister should be able to manage this team for 4 or 5 runs a game. Torre works with a pencil, not a bat. Our team is pure offense. Now Torre is a shit for NOT bunting?
Damon/Jetes/Shef/ARod/Giambi/Matsui: 1 for 21.
I know Joe is an easy target, but over $80 million (1-6) MUST do better then ONE for TWENTY ONE!
It would be great if Torre helps us out over these types of games... but even better strategy (we can't read the future) may not have won either. A few walks and hits however....
Of those 5(+1) quality starts the Yankees have won 2(+1). The offense cost The Big Unit a win in the 3-2 loss to Oakland when he pitched a complete game. Mussina's two losses have also both been quality starts.
The flip side to that is that we've stolen 2 non-quality starts from the clutches of defeat. The Yankee Stadium Opening Day game started by Wang was one, and the other was the following night when Chacon gave up 5 runs over 6 innings. Jaret Wright and the aforementioned Chacon lost the other two non-quality outings for the Yanks.
It boils down to Johnson and Mussina pitching well, and getting short changed by the offense, and the rest of the pitchers spitting the bit every time out. Will it improve...I think so....will it be good enough to win it all....hard to say, but it has to get A LOT better before that's realistic, I think.
Quality Starts
6 out of 10 (3-3)
Non-Quality Starts
4 out of 10 (2-2)
If the law of averages held up we'd be 6-4 right now, so we're not far off. It's the fact that no one other than Johnson or Moose has made a QS yet that bugs me.
The point is, right now the Yankees just don't match up terribly well with teams - like Minnesota and Oakland - that can pitch, play sound defense, and hit well situationally. As cliche as that sounds, it's true. And, in my opinion, a team that you don't match up well with is a better team than yours.
Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.