Baseball Toaster Bronx Banter
Pretty Damn Good
2008-07-14 08:50
by Alex Belth


Rob Neyer has a fine appreciation of Bobby Murcer's career today at ESPN:

After playing briefly for the Yankees in 1965 and '66, Murcer was one of the very few major leaguers drafted into the military during the Vietnam War. Inducted into the army during spring training in 1967, he missed all of that season and the next while serving as a radio operator. Murcer worried that his career was over, but would later tell author Philip Bashe, "What I thought was going to be a horrible experience was really a positive thing for me in the long run. I learned responsibility and, obviously, a little bit of discipline. When I got out I was ready to proceed with my baseball career on a much more mature level."

No kidding. Murcer, who had struggled in the majors before going into the army -- understandably, considering that he'd been a 160-pound teenager -- got off to a brilliant start in 1969. He homered on Opening Day and drove in three runs. He homered in his next game, too. When Murcer hurt his ankle in late May, he was leading the majors with 43 RBIs.

He cooled off after getting back into the lineup, but still led the club with 82 runs and 82 RBIs. Also that season, Murcer finally moved into Mantle's old spot in center field. Murcer, like Mantle, had been a shortstop in the minors, and he'd stuck there during his first stints with the Yankees. But in 1969 they moved him to third base, an experiment that lasted five weeks and included 14 errors. He spent the next months in right field, and finally moved to center in late August; the transition was complete, and in 1972 Murcer won a Gold Glove (something Mantle never did).

In 1971, Murcer's first great season (and his best), he played in his first of five straight All-Star Games. They didn't all come with the Yankees, though. In 1974, Murcer became the highest-paid Yankee ever -- his $120,000 salary topped the $100,000 earned by Joe DiMaggio and Mantle. But Murcer hit only 10 home runs in 1974, and shortly after the season the Yankees traded him to the Giants for Bobby Bonds.

Shea Stadium is what really did-in the first leg of Murcer's career with the Yanks. Not only did his power vanish but he was unceremoniously replaced in center field in the middle of the season. Murcer missed the Yankees three straight pennants in the late '70s but returned as a bench player in '79 and was around in the '81 Serious. Neyer continues:

As a player, Murcer has been both overappreciated and underappreciated. In the 1970s he was one of the game's more famous players, because he played for the Yankees and had plenty of flair. He was, by the common definition of the term, a superstar. However, he was a great player for only four seasons: 1970 to 1973.

On the other hand, as is often the case with very good players with a broad range of skills, history has not been kind to Murcer. Would you believe he was just as good as Andre Dawson and Tony Oliva, both of whom might one day be elected to the Hall of Fame? He was. Would you believe he was quite a bit better than Roger Maris? He was. At his best, Murcer routinely hit 25 home runs, scored 90 and knocked in 90. And in Murcer's era, those numbers meant something.


2008-07-14 09:47:00
1.   JohnnyC
Mantle won a Gold Glove in 1962, Rob. Typical for Neyer.
2008-07-14 09:58:40
2.   Josh Wilker
In his Historical Abstract book, Bill James chose Murcer as the best centerfielder of the 1970s.
2008-07-14 10:07:50
3.   dianagramr
Curse you Gabe Paul ...


2008-07-14 10:51:35
4.   JL25and3
3 The thing is, the trade was the right move. It hurt, but it was a good trade - and it led to an even better one.
2008-07-14 10:52:38
5.   JL25and3
I'd make the case that in 1971, Murcer was the best position player in the league. He was only 7th in the MVP voting, presumably because the Yankees' record dropped off considerably that year.
2008-07-14 11:07:33
6.   Cliff Corcoran
Murcer's 1971 season was a monster despite underwhelming cumulative stats. He hit .331/.427/.543 with a 181 OPS+ (by comparison Alex Rodriguez's career best OPS+ was his 177 last year), led the league in OBP, OPS, OPS+, runs created, and times on base, was second in average, slugging, and runs, third in total bases and fourth in hits, walks, and RBIs. He walked 91 times against just 60 strikeouts.

Despite doing all that while playing a strong center field, he finished a distant seventh in the MVP voting. Vida Blue was the deserving winner, and the Yankees were a middling team (82-80, 22 games out in fourth place), but among the players finishing ahead of Murcer was Freddy Patek, slap-hitting shortstop of of the 85-win Royals who had a sub-par 97 OPS+.

I'd rank Bobby's '71 season as one of the must underappreciated seasons in Yankee history.

2008-07-14 13:42:42
7.   Bruce Markusen
JL, I have mixed feelings about the Murcer-Bonds deal. On the one hand, Bonds was the more talented of the two and turned in a very good season in 1975. And then Bonds turned into Rivers and Figueroa, which was a very good trade.

But there were drawbacks. With the trade of Murcer, the Yankees had one legitimate left-handed power hitter in Graig Nettles. Chris Chambliss was not yet hitting with power, while Ron Blomberg was often hurt. If the Yankees had held onto Murcer, he would have been back at the renovated Stadium in 1976, where he would have been much more comfortable than at Shea Stadium.

And then there was Murcer's popularity. All in all, a tough call.

Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.