Baseball Toaster was unplugged on February 4, 2009.
There is some sad news to report on this rainy afternoon in New York. Jim Kaat is retiring. Tonight and tomorrow will be his final two broadcasts for the Yankees. While I had heard that Kaat might call it quits at the end of the year, all of sudden, he's going to be gone. I don't exactly know why he's leaving before the end of the season. I can only speculate that Kaat didn't want to call attention to himself as everyone around him was gearing up for the playoffs. Regardless, Kaat deserves a long, loud ovation from Yankee fans near and far for the steady and insightful work he's provided over the years.
Man, I'm not ready to see him go and I've been feeling upset about it all morning long. I haven't always agreed with Kaat's analysis, but I have never had anything but the utmost respect for his professionalism, his eloquence and his willingness to speak his mind. He is a terrific storyteller, has an easy-going sense of humor, and has been a wonderfully measured prescence in the Yankee Universe. I remember my uncle spotting him in a bank on the Upper West Side during his stint with the Yanks at the end of his playing career, and I've always thought of him as a guy who appreciated New York City, and come to think of him as one of our (adopted) own. Richard Sandomir has a piece on Kitty today in the Times. The YES Network will have a tribute to Kaat up on their website later this afternoon, or perhaps this evening.
Kitty, you haven't even left yet and I'm missing you already. But here is wishing Kaat the best of times with his grandchildren and on the golf course down in Florida.
Iirc his ml career started in 1959, so that by the late 70s the type on his stats on the back of the card was absolutely miniscule. I thought it was so cool, and can still remember when the 80s hit and he'd played in4 decades.
I wasn't a big card collector, so I don't recall what his card looked like in 83, his last season, but I suspect by then a magnifying glass was needed.
http://biobasicsglobal.com/EBAY8/DSC08958.JPG
(sorry, TinyURL is blocked at work)
(Tony actually tried to understand things before he gave his opinion on their usefulness.
We'll miss ya, Kitty. Enjoy.
That's my take, but I don't recall the particulars all that well. 'Lil help...
I'm not allowed to have an opinion? I know of quite a few other Yankee fans that can't stand Kay, Sterling, Waldman, and Kaat. Some of them refer to Kaat as "Uncle Stupid" because of the ridiculous reamrks he makes. His obvious dislike for some Yankees and hero worship for others is unprofessional (not having to hear how "Jeter's compact swing generates more power than Arod's, which is too long." any more is just fine with me.)
I grew up listening to Mel Allen and Red Barber. Then Scooter, Frank Messer, Bill White, Tony Kubek, etc. Guys who didn't try to psychoanalyze players, but reported on the events in the game (or in Scooter's case, were entertaining enough to not do so.)
Singleton is most like them,though he gets dragged into the psychobabble from time to time.
In any case, I think I'll reserve the right to criticize who I please. And I'm the guy that defends players far more often than criticizes them.
Yes! in my card-collecting days of the late 70's, I always loved seeing the amount of stats the "old-timers" had on the back of their cards, and Kaat's was always some of the smallest type I'd ever seen.
I also find him too McCarverish - his observations sometimes come out as pronouncements, calling attention to himself as much as to the observation.
Singleton is my current favorite. The game he did solo was an understated tour de force - I didn't realize for several innings that he was alone.
It reminds me having lunch with coworkers and one of the guys said he just saw Forrest Gump and thought it was the dumbest movie he ever saw. Another guy pipes in and says maybe he didn't understand the movie cause he happened to like it.
I think maybe he just didn't like the movie.
I know I didn't like the movie Chicago, though others clearly did.
Sometimes it is OK to agree to disagree.
"Phil Rizzuto, a Yankees broadcaster for 39 years, a member of the Hall of Fame and perhaps the most popular announcer in New York, said Friday he has quit his job.
Rizzuto, 76, decided to resign after he missed the funeral of Mickey Mantle in Texas on Tuesday. At the behest of station executives at WPIX-TV, Rizzuto stayed in Boston and broadcast the Yankees-Red Sox game.
He left the booth after five innings, too distraught to continue, and left the stadium.
"After I saw the funeral on television, I said, `This is terrible.' I'll never be able to make up for that. If I had a little more get-up-and-go, I would have just gone on down to the funeral and let the chips fall where they may.
"I think I've definitely made up my mind, even though everybody keeps telling me I can't do this," Rizzuto said.
WPIX executives asked Rizzuto to reconsider his decision, "and he said he would," station vice president Michael Eigner said.
The next WPIX broadcast is Sunday from Anaheim. The station broadcasts 41 Yankees games a year; the rest are on cable. Rizzuto said he has an open-ended ticket to California in case he changes his mind.
"I've been there for 39 years and I'm not tired or anything, but I had relegated my family to the background, and when I saw what Mickey said about that, I thought it was about time," Rizzuto said.
Eigner said WPIX did not forbid Rizzuto from going to the funeral but wanted him to broadcast the game Tuesday because Yankees fans would want to hear Rizzuto's voice on a tribute the station had prepared.
Also, fellow announcer Bobby Murcer was a pallbearer at the funeral, and the absence of Murcer and Rizzuto would have left only one announcer in the booth.
I never really warmed up to Kaat in the way I did to the Scooter. I guess it's the difference in growing up with one and listening to the other as an adult. I didn't always agree with Kaat's opinions or follow the logic of his arguments but I did always respect him and feel that he did the games as honestly as he possibly could.
I hope Kitty has a great time seeing the country in that RV of his. Take it easy big guy, we'll leave a light on and a bowl of milk on the porch for you.
They could have simulcasted the radio broadcast or something, no?
FWIW, I would pay a lot of money to hear Scooter and White call a current Yankees game. Doesn't matter who the 3rd guy is, Seaver, Murcer, Messer, or even if there is one. Wait, I take that back. I don't think I could bear to listen to Kubek or McCarver or Joe Morgan ruin it for me.
I too won't miss Kitty's crazy talk about pitch counts etc - but because he's generally pretty even-minded about everything else, I can ignore his tragic flaw. Unlike, say, "All the radar guns are wrong! I know a 102 mph pitch and that wasn't it" Joe Morgan, who's tragic flaw, his broadcasting career, is sadly impossible to ignore if one likes watching baseball with the volume on as I do.
For those who might still have a tiny bit of worry deep in their souls:
BP Postseason Odds
Yanks:
AL East - 99.99630
Wild Card - .00010
Overall - 99.99640
Red Sox:
AL East - .00330
Wild Card - .04928
Overall - .05258
Sweet.
One guy I never could care for is Vin Scully. For some reason his voice and the way he announces (his stories, et al.,) just rub me the wrong way. The fact that it is Dodgers' games he's announcing doesn't help, either.
I don't care how hard announcing is. It's apparently not too hard for some people and much too hard for others.
I agree that Morgan and McCarver are worse, but the constant "this whole thing where a catcher has to hit, that started with Johnny Bench. I don't care if a guy hits 100 if he can do a good job behind the plate." He says that pretty much every game (along with several other absurdities) and it's idiotic. For one thing, there have been excellent offensive catchers since the dead ball era, including Steve O'Niell, Mickey Cochrane, Wally Shang, Hank Severeid, Johnny Bassler, Bubbles Hargrave, Frank Snyder, Gabby Hartnett, Mickey Cochrane, and Bill Dickey (all who played in the 1920s) right through to the present. Saying it all started with Bench one time is excusable. Saying it every other broadcast is nails on a blackboard to anyone that's even midly interested in baseball history. And I can't imagine many pitchers really not wanting a guy that drives in 90 runs as opposed to a guy hitting 100 in the line-up no matter where they play.
Ditto Power hitting shortstops, another silliness he often injects into his broadcasts.
Along with pitch counts, radar guns, throwing breaking balls,and over-analyzing a players psyche (another field he knows zero about but talks about at great length.)
If you're going to be making pronouncements game after game, at least try to learn if there's a lick of accuracy in them.
What is wrong with embellishments? When they are used to ignore the merit in what someone is saying or the value of their contributions they serve only one purpose - to make yourself feel better about yourself.
You're never going to agree with an announcer 100% of the time.
For me, the best ones are not intrusive, but are easy on the ear, and offer relevant observations. Kitty was all that, and then some, providing fun and insightful baseball stories which were almost always relevant to the game situation.
At least that's how I heard him.
Great work, Jim Kaat. I'm gonna miss you.
Thankfully, we still have Singleton.
Of course if you want you can always find something about any announcer that you don't like (someone earlier even said that they didn't like Vin Scully). With three hours of time to fill in a sometimes slow game, it has got to be difficult to be fresh and creative every night.
Overall, I think Kaat does a great job and I will surely miss him. Those who don't like him should try listening to Hawk Harrelson, Joe Morgan, Tim McCarver or Tom Paciorek on a regular basis.
We've got it way, way better than most Yankee fans realize, not that there's no room for improvement.
Are we going to get this game in? Weather Channel says 70% chance of rain all night. It'll be sloppy but I figure they'll try to squeeze it in.
I always liked Kitty. They've been talking about his retirement for weeks now, but I still find it hard to believe he's really going. I guess I can't blame him for wanting to retire, though. I know I would if I could!
All of you locals to the NY area have no idea how good you have it, regarding announcers. I will miss Kitty, I think he is the best of the TV pack, and wish it was Kay who was the one who is leaving.
Kaye is lousy.
I've always had a soft spot for Sterling -- his enthusiasm for baseball just makes me smile, no matter how inane or repetitive. I wish he'd drop his stupid home run calls ("robbie cano, don't you know ..." etc). Waldman is ok.
Up here in Boston, Orsillo and Remy on TV are both excellent. But Castiglione and Trupiano on the radio are like nails on a blackboard ...
The Ghost Sox are probably the closest thing the Yanks will see to a playoff opponent until next month, so it will be a nice tune up series for the starters.
And FWIW, the Mudhens' announcers (spilt between radio and tv) are pretty good.
Score early, Yanks!
Tommy John is one of the Charlotte Knights' color guys. He annoyed me at first, because he's a real chatty Kathy. Talks constantly - to the point that the play-by-play guy can't get a word in edgewise (which means sometimes you're left wondering what the heck is going on in the game). But he kind of grew on me. He was interesting. At least he talked about baseball, if not about the game being played. Unlike the ESPN guys, who talk about things not remotely related to baseball.
While I don't have the knowledge of the game that many do here, I often suspected some/much of Kaat's analysis was BS, but I enjoyed him on an more elemental level, just the tone and cadence of his voice seemed to work well for baseball broadcasts. That voice also seemed to contrast well with both Singleton's and Murcer's. I grew up with Rizzuto and White, and I consider the current crop (minus Kaye, though I don't dislike him as strongly as some here) pretty comparable to them.
Kaat also had some of the best "ex-player" stories among broadcasters.
And one on level it pains me to say it, but as someone with the Extra Innings package who watches a LOT of baseball in addition to the Yanks, Remy and Orsillo are the best broadcasters I've listened to. Knowledge of the game, good voices for broadcasting (especially Orsillo's) and while they clearly root for the Sox, they are always quick to give credit and respect to opponents when due.
I know people love Vin Scully, but listening to his meandering stories about what the shortstop does in the off-season up in his hunting cabin in Montana drives me nuts. I suspect the Royals guys are often drunk (though watching 162 games of KC ineptitude might drive me to the bottle), and the White Sox crew I find the most openly partisan. The SF guys aren't too bad, but for some reason Giants home broadcasts really cut the crowd noise, so they sound like they're in some small room across the Bay watching it on TV.
I'm also slightly embarrassed to admit I've been enjoying the Met broadcasts with Hernandez and Darling. They're a little goofy but generally entertaining (kind of like the Mets, I guess...)
Bernie
Jeter
Cano
A-Rod
Giambi
Jorgie
Matsui
Guiel
KT
Karstens P
Bernie CF
Jeter SS
Cano 2B
A-Rod 3B
Giambi 1B
Jorgie C
Matsui DH
Guiel RF
Thompson LF
Karstens P
All the starting OFers are getting the night off.
My favorite is Jim Palmer-very well spoken and one of the smartest (is it odd that two of the best announcers came from Earl Weaver's O's? I don't think it is.)
I've never understodd the animosity to homers. If Hawk Harrelson wants to openly root for the Chisox, why shouldn't he? I'd rather listen to somebody root for the team they cover than pretend to be impartial.
I agree with whoever lumped Kaat with McCarver and that group. And I agree that he's light years better than Kay and Waldman (and they're both much better than the god-awful Joe Morgan.)
http://www.dispatch.com/news-story.php?story=212440
Sterling has a great voice, calls the game well, and yeah he gets excited win the Yanks homer or win, but when the other team homers I hear excitement in his voice as I did last night when Baldelli homered.
Waldman is terrible. Maybe she is the problem -- bring back Charlie Steiner?
===
It is believed that Yankees general manager Brian Cashman wants his triple-A team closer to New York. Scranton, Pa., approximately 120 miles west of New York City, is available since the Philadelphia Phillies allowed their contract to lapse. The team currently known as the Scranton/Wilkes-Barre Red Barrons will play in Allentown in 2008, and Philadelphia is rumored to be planning to play its top minor-league team in Ottawa for the 2007 season.
===
Good news on the Liriano kid at ESPN.com. Lefties who can throw like he does are a gift from god. Gotta root for him getting back on the field in one piece.
I guess I understand why the announcers on local networks are homers, since their games are usually only seen by fans of the local team. But with a national network and with the advent of EI and MLB.TV they should realize that some people might be watching the game and actually rooting for the other team.
To me it's kind of like watching a game in your living room with a fan of another team. Would you want to watch a Yankees-Red Sox game with a Boston fan openly rooting against you in your living room? If you are at the game or in a bar it's understandable, but if he does it in my living room that Boston fan would probably leave with more than a bloody sock...
Joe, worrying about the wet outfield, decided to bench all the first stringers. Which mean moving Bernie to CF, and putting Guiel and Thompson in the corners.
Arrghh. I know it doesn't matter now, but jeez...Bernie? You've got Guiel, and Thompson, and Wilson, who are all adequate corner OFers, and it's Bernie he puts in?
I hate to say it, but the best local TV announcers I've watched this year are the Mets guys when Hernandez is there.
Worst, without question: the Nationals. Way too homerish, in a fake way, and without an ounce of insight.
70 Travis, boy did you nail those Nats broadcast clowns to a T. You cannot listen to the broadcast, believe me I've tried. Talk about phoney baloney passion, it's a freakin nightmare. All that sturm and drang about the NESN broadcast rights and they give us this dreck? Oye.
Had this to say:
Bernie leading of and Matsui batting 7th means that at this point in the season Joe feels more comfortable with GOB hitting more in a game than he does Godzilla....stunning.
How about:
Jeter
Cano
A-Rod
Giambi
Posada
Matsui
GOB
Guiel
Thompson
Doesn't that make more sense?
Melky and Godzilla are both experienced center fielders. Joe has defined Melky as purely a left fielder. He has said the Matsui will only DH. When Johnny Damon doesn't start in a post-season game, I think Bernie will start in his place.
Exactly. I also think he'd start Bernie in the corners first, if any of the starters can't play.
It was interesting to read his comments in the Post (?) today about his general unhappiness about playing time. I mean, wasn't his role supposed to be PH-ing, DH-ing and spelling the OFers occassionally? The only reason he got more playing time is because of all the injuries...and now he's bitching? C'mon!
Meanwhile, 23, baby!
Trails Mauer by 2 points.
It was interesting to read his comments in the Post (?) today about his general unhappiness about playing time. I mean, wasn't his role supposed to be PH-ing, DH-ing and spelling the OFers occassionally? The only reason he got more playing time is because of all the injuries...and now he's bitching? C'mon!
Meanwhile, 23, baby!
::shakes fist at the stupid internet connection::
If he's still complaining, then put together a little best of dvd of his outfield play over the last 2-3 seasons.
I love you Bernie, but you're an old fart.
When Damon was having his back problems, and Bernie played CF two days in a row, he went 0 for 5 the second day. He gets visibly tired after playing CF, or even DHing two or three days in a row.
I grew up on The Scooter, Coleman and Joe G. They were more entertaining then most sitcoms... for a Yankee team that stunk. I was to young to know if they were 'any good', but I loved them.
But even Scooter told some stories over and over, and had his own schtick (sp?). No announcer is perfect, and they do have to fill an incredible amount of time. All in all, Kitty was one of the best, and I will certainly miss him.
Is Leiter his replacement?
I swear, he's even better now than he was before he broke his wrist.
102 Like 106 says, Bernie with the bat is fine. Bernie with the glove, not so much. I love him, he's one of my favorites, but I also look at things objectively. Bernie in the field at this point is detrimental to the team. Not bashing him, just stating the obvious. If you don't agree, that's fine, but let's call a spade a spade...
For Mr. Steady, Joe Torre, this is like 'winging it'. And we're still gonna win the game.
Lets have some fun. Maybe we will even see Donnie PH.
.255/.298/.380
I mean, c'mon dude, that Womackian territory.
We can beat up on Torre for playing Womack, but we can't when he does the same with Bernie cause he used to be a great player?
Nice play KT!
Just please respect Joe's relationship with Bernie, and accept that he's going to play him from time to time, especially if he knows or thinks this might be Bernie's finall weeks.
I don't think Joe will put Bernie in a situation where he will hurt the team in October. In other words, as wsporter posted above, it's very unlikely he'll be put in the field next month, unless it's in a blow out.
Columbus remains a city in Ohio, beyond that who knows. ;-)
Cashman might be more hard-headed. I'm hoping he'll convince Bernie to sign on as a coach or something instead.
And promise him headliner status at a nightclub in the new Yankee Stadium from 2009.
I was listening to an interview with Papi this afternoon on one of the baseball shows on XM, and I didn't expect much, but he started going off on how the media was blowing up his comments out of proportion because of the coming series with the Yankees, and how unfair and "low" it was for "the media" to make it appear that he didn't respect Jeter.
In other words, it's all a media creation, and of course, Papi went on to suck up to the Cap about how great a player he is, how everyone in baseball loves to see him play, bla bla bla.
I really think Ortiz is a good guy who got caught being a little too honest in front of the mike, and he definitely said a couple of really dumb things -- anyone as media-savvy as him should never be caught saying anything like "come hit in this lineup, and see how you do". But he's between a rock and a hard place now -- he can't be too candid about how dumb his comments were, because that would imply that he did have less respect for Jeter's credentials relative to Dye or Morneau or any other big bopper, even if he's apologetic and remorseful post-brainfart.
Major media simply doesn't let stars off the hook that easy with comments like that, and you wonder what Jetes himself thinks and how much of a grudge he's going to hold.
So Ortiz is now crying about being a victim of "the media". It sounds pretty bad, though...really insincere whining, honestly, and very uncharacteristic of him. I think he's better off saying he's spoken to Jeter privately, and that he won't talk about the matter any more.
Columbus will now try to get the Mets or some other team to make the Clippers their Triple-A team.
However, in the 'throwing teammates under the bus' category, in his 'apology', he stated he wanted to be square with the media and "not be like Ramirez". Poor schmuck.
Twinkies will probably win tonight...I'm hoping for a massive 3-way tie in the Central, so they have to play a playoff game and beat the crud out of each other ;-)
Yarrrgh!
Cap now tied with Mauer at .346.
202 Good job ;-)
But how did Crawford drop that?
He may have been looking at the wall instead of at the ball.
Cano with RISP, post-injury: .420, 37 RBI (21 for 50)
Sooo....exit URP starter, enter URP reliever?
PH Wilson for Giambi!
(Tho everyone blames RJ for spitting the bit in that game, it was tough to ask him to pitch in those conditions. I knew at the time that he wouldn't be able to stride into his pitches, and would leave the ball up therefore.)
And screw you, MLB.tv... I am going to win my Fantasy League, I'm no liar! Ryan Howard, Bobby Abreu, Carlos Beltran and Justin Verlander have powered me to victory!
with all due respect to our man brian bruney, he's making a STRONG impression to make a last-ditch attempt at the PS roster.
btw. . .anyone else going to root for these d-rays next year? i feel like they can all get better together.
Honestly, though, if the Devil Rays play the 2007 lineup that Cliff mentioned, and can get Jae Seo back to last year's form, they might be competitive with another one or two pitchers. Any thoughts on who's worth pursuing for our friends over in Tampa? Obviously no Zito for these guys. . .but what about someone like Jason Jennings?
Just tuning in, on the road so I can't watch. Except this is watching.
Here we go, Yankees, here we go!
;-)
301...oh yes he did!!!
a comeback lead AND Boston is losing to Baltimore again (as of right now). Pretty good night in my book!
"Padding the stats", eh? I mean, I'll take it.
Does anyone know what the numbers are for typical increase in batting production for a guy Cano's age? I think it's gotta be huge. On average.
What happened to Jorgie???
Fred Dunlap
Tony Lazzeri
Paul Molitor
Billy Herman
Those last three are HOFers...
324 Ah, thanks. Very interesting. I'll take Tony Lazzeri, thank you very much.
http://www.baseball-reference.com/d/dunlafr01.shtml
332 You have to ask that question? You don't live in New England. Ortiz is the hearthrob; Manny is his supporting cast.
Jorgie swung at the pitch, missed with the bat...but didn't miss with his back elbow.
Very nice, big K for Rasner, though. And he gets TyWig, too.
I'm yammering. (Just trying to make up for lost time.)
Yeah, bad choice of words.
Love these Yankees though!
http://www.baseball-reference.com/leagues/UA_1884_t.shtml
Jeter .346
Mauer .345
Jeter .346
Mauer .345
Cano .339
It wasn't a home run, but that worked out okay, right?
Props to Bernie and Joe.
The Nats let him go because they thought they had roster issues. They did have issues but they let the wrong guy go. If he gets the shot I think he'll do the job.
Two 26 year olds. One getting paid 4.5 million and has an ERA over 5, the other getting paid 350K and is 17-5.
::happy dance::
My next choice would be for him to fulfill his need to play baseball with another franchise. It didn't sully the reputation of Tino Martinez in the Bronx, and I don't think anyone would hold it against him. Then maybe he can come back and sign a ST contract with the Yanks and retire, like the 49ers did with Jerry Rice. I guess what I'm trying to say is that I hope the end of Bernie's career is blessed with as much grace as he showed in his prime, in covering centerfield at Yankee Stadium.
Looks like Mauer gets another shot after all. Twinks are smacking it in the eighth.
How good was this guy supposed to be?
Camden Yards has a serious RSN infestation problem, doesn't it....
Hats off.
I mean, the Red Sox started sucking and ESPN had nothing to lead off SportsCenter for a good 2-3 weeks there...
Ah, of course. ESPN2 is all done now. Schmucks.
Well, no matter. Either way (Sox W or L), we clinch by taking three of four, and not by splitting. So.
Whatever happend to (N)ESPN?
Having Chen versus Ortiz is like throwing rocks at a man with a machine gun, to quote Rowdy Piper.
417 Dang. Maybe Mauer gets the day off against Carmona?
"If Liriano comes back, the Yanks have absolutely no chance to beat the Twins in the playoffs."
Baseball genius.
427 Stephen A. Smith is the man who thought a team could miss a field goal on 3rd down and get the ball back.
Huh, so Smith's talents extend beyond baseball.
Stupid Angelos.
Nice try, LI yankee.
O's blow
Well, we couldn't get any help tonight, but the pinstripes did their job. The real fun is coming up soon.
Have a GOOD night.
'night, y'all!
Wonder if Manny will play this series? The last time he played was on Sept. 9th.
157 Damn, and all the time I lived in Cincy, I had no idea there was fun stuff in Columbus.
Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.